Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Terminator

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    22,141
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    121

 Content Type 

Profiles

Toronto Blue Jays Videos

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Top Prospect Rankings

Toronto Blue Jays Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Toronto Blue Jays Fan Guides & Resources

2025 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Toronto Blue Jays News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Toronto Blue Jays Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Terminator

  1. Extend Mattingly
  2. He had a -12 Statcast fielding run value last year in just 84 games in the field. It was so bad that he's only played 1 inning in the field this year.
  3. Yeah that is definitely possible. Opting in is the equivalent of signing a one year $27M deal, with a player option for 25 mil tacked on. Could he do better than that?
  4. This plan makes sense to me but unless Loperfido or Barger end the season on fire I think we need another OF bat. There are tons of them on the market this year too. Tier 1- not happening Soto Tier 2- will take a multi-year deal Bellinger Teoscar Santander O'Neill Tier 3- one or two year deal Conforto (boring but would actually fit) Verdugo (yuck) Bader (not what we need) Kepler (would also fit but never healthy) Winker (too risky) Profar (too risky)
  5. McMahon isn't that bad! Great defender and although his bat isn't great, he bats left handed which is great. Could spell him with Ernie once in a while. His AAV is fine. The problem is that old man Monfort has a crush on him and considers him to be an actual friend. In fact he considers everyone in the organization a close personal friend so that's why he never fires or trades anyone. So they'll never trade him.
  6. That was such a stupid signing. They are lucky that he's even this good. Really bad body type for baseball as he's built like an NFL RB. Short and squatty and not very athletic. I can see why scouts panned the signing when it happened. He's almost entirely reliant on a very good hit tool. If that was just average he'd be below replacement value.
  7. the playoffs will be easy to make
  8. That might matter a little bit but not sure how much. If you gain runs via offense you'll probably just give them back via defense and the bottom line doesn't change much. Just take the value wherever you can get it.
  9. Right, but you can see the angle they were going for. If he hits 110 wRC+, which I believe he was projected to do at the time, he's an All-Star and should flirt with a Top 5 MVP vote tally. Dude's bat has turned into an almost worst-case scenario and the trade is just kind of meh.
  10. Further to the Varsho in LF point, CF gets a +2.5 positional adjustment and LF/RF get -7.5. So that's 10 runs or a total of 1 win, which seems significant. But that's per 162 games. Nobody is playing that many games so that eats into the run total a little bit. Then factor in that Varsho played 64 games in CF last year and that eats into it even more. Then there's whatever value comes from not having to carry a 4th OF who can play CF (or carrying one that can't really play CF that well). By the time you factor all that in, Varsho's WAR probably got dinged by about 0.2 or so. KK putting up a fat WAR number more than made up for that in '23. Didn't work in 2022.
  11. Yeah bringing him back in 2024 was not the right move. But they don't think in terms of just adding offense like fans do. They try and add value to the team in the most efficient way possible. KK put up nearly a 4 bWAR season last year and 2.8 fWAR which has always hated KK's defense for some reason. Yeah those numbers weren't repeatable but they weren't paying for him to repeat that. They were hoping to get a couple of WAR out of him. His bat completely cratered so it didn't work out, but it also illustrates just how unique of a player he is when he can hit like a pitcher but still put up 0.5 bWAR and 0.1 fWAR.
  12. The Varsho in LF thing is so overblown IMO. It worked out amazingly in year 1. They doubled down on KK in Year 2 and it didn't work, but it's not because Varsho was playing a lot of LF, it was because KK sucked.
  13. Don Mattingly did the impossible, he fixed Vlad Jr.'s swing. Both deserve big extensions.
  14. Yeah Loperfido's defense gives him the edge over Fisher. Even with his slow start at the plate he is accumulating WAR and even if he doesn't improve much there he can be a 4th OF so long as he remains cheap. The general concern that both have Quad-A bats is pretty similar though.
  15. Is Vlad seen as better than Matt Olson was when he signed his extension? Olson was coming off of a 5 WAR season and entering his age 28 year. Vlad will be coming off a similar season and will be entering his age 26 season. Vlad will be able to get more than Olson but it's a good baseline.
  16. I hear you. Analysts often get blown away by the size of contracts. Sometimes the reverse happens though like last year. And the market has changed since the Prince Fielder days. 1B is one of the lesser paid positions now. Matt Olson is a better comparison.
  17. Nice to see them finally roll the dice on a high ceiling guy like Nimmala. If we are going to run Top 5-10 payrolls I kind of like the strategy of trying to hit home runs through the farm system. We can sign 2 WAR guys whenever we want.
  18. I think Passan is right in that the team should wait for FA to play out and try and extend him after Alonso signs. Start negotiations at the beginning of February. I also wonder if he'd be interested in a deferred contract which would superficially pump his number up and also technically make him the highest paid 1B. Not sure how to calculate the deferrals out but let's say he technically got 10 for 300, but enough of it was in deferrals so it was actually 10 for 200 for CBT purposes. Adjust those numbers how you see fit but I wonder if something like that could help make it work for both sides?
  19. Yeah maybe that's wrong. I think I read that on Fangraphs within the past year or two but maybe the narrative is changing. It's hard to quantify too because of a poor team's player hits FA he's guaranteed to be gone.
  20. Nope. It seems like the online fan narrative is that he will want 300M and the team will want to come in under 200. Fans seem to land on 240ish or so? I think the casuals are okay with higher and the stat nerds think below 200.
  21. I think it's very rare for players to go back to their team once they hit free agency.
  22. Yep and Edgar Martinez would get about 7 added or so. Both make sense as it would put Ortiz over 60 WAR, thus making him a bon a fide, but not spectacular HoFer. Edgar would be a cut above that at 72 WAR.
  23. They are under but they are limited on the moves they can make the rest of the year is what it sounds like to me. Can't make endless waiver claims, maybe can't call Votto up, etc. because they are close to the line and those things could push them over. That said, there aren't a ton of moves to be made at this point so it should be fine.
  24. It's tough to say what the prices will be. Chapman was aiming for similar and had to settle for way less.
  25. His 87th percentile 2B defense is holding! Up to +4 OAA on the season. Amazing transformation.
×
×
  • Create New...