I really hope Vizquel can inch up every year so we can get a decade of raging debate over this. Like Morris. I recall a thesis for Blyleven that his vote total went up as the writers were getting more sympathetic to the new stats. Guess that's not the case with Vizquel. He being in the position he is in is simple. He's seen as the 90's Ozzie Smith, a tad lower on defense but also a tad higher on offense (counting stats, but not RC+). Therefore Omar Vizquel = Ozzie Smith.
You can look at fangraphs stat sheets and JAWS and assess some random number. Let's say 55 WAR where above that everyone gets in on the first ballot and below that everyone is eliminated on the first ballot. But where is the fun in that? Like it or not, for whatever reason Vizquel has had a greater impact in the collective memories of baseball writers than superior players like Kenny Lofton, the CF version of Vizquel except better in every way, or Yankee playoff hero David Wells. Both of whom immediately fell off of the ballot. The curiosity of baseball.