I've said McCarthy has been a very good pitcher this season, though I have to disagree on him being one of the best pitchers in baseball to date. It's absurd to rank him in a tier with Tanaka, Kershaw, Felix, Wainwright, Sale etc.
They did steal him, not denying that. I would have loved to see the Jays trade Jenkins for him. But I don't consider McCarthy one of the best pitchers in baseball.
I've been an avid McCarthy supporter and I know the advanced metrics show he hasn't been that bad, though to say he's been one of the best pitchers in the NL is going a bit far.
Look at the post above...I said I received messages on the pro board site. I usually check on the message board here. I now linked any pm's sent on the pro boards site to my email.
I'd like to see two teams in a dynasty league make a trade involving players traded in real life, though that would be tough to do. Never think I saw it happen.
I checked on the ProBoards site and got messages there. I have to set up where I get notified on my gmail since I don't check frequently on those sites as I do on the message board.