I'd probably rank Lucroy ahead of Vogt based on age and previous production.
Also, I'd probably throw a healthy Devin Mesoraco in the Top 5 over vets like McCann and Martin. He's still only 27 and last season posted a 147 wRC+ (obviously needs to be healthy though). Kyle Schwarber is an interesting name as well who I'd likely take over some vets since this is dynasty.