Yeah a lot of rational posters on here I think agree that Ross Atkins wasn't a bad GM and was actually solid. He made some great moves which I and many like you acknowledge. However there is a cult on this board that praises the floor Atkins walks on 24/7 which irks me. It feels like this team hasn't taken advantage of their window given and I saw those warning signs during the 2021 season. Even this offseason, the goal was to add some power to the lineup after a disastrous 2023, and they failed to do that.
Also, can't blame everything on Atkins. Guerrero and Bo have been awful to start the season. Warning signs of Vladdy not being elite have been there since 2022, so I think it's time to move on after this season. I think Bo will figure it out at some point. Springer is an old broken down player now whose contract is immovable.
I think this team needs fresh eyes to lead this team through the end of the Bo & Vlad era. Right now the farm system hasn't produced much to be excited about and this roster is an old, aging and expensive roster, including the pitching. I think the window is near a close. The team is likely still an 85 win team with strong pitching and defense, but any regression in those areas, the results likely will be worse.