Grichuk.
Acquisitions like McKinney, Hernandez, Drury, Paulino, Merryweather, Thornton, Perez, Espinal, Spanberger, etc. need to be given a few years before they can be judged.
Bautista was mediocre his first ~500 PA with Toronto. Edwin 900 PA - to the point that AA literally waived him and got extremely lucky to get him back from Oakland.
Kind of weird that you would even reference players like Lawrie, Morrow, Rasmus, Yunel when they had nothing to do with Toronto's playoff teams. I guess they were exciting value-based acquisitions. Atkins has made different forms of value-based acquisitions though; their whole MO has been value-hoarding at all levels of the org.