Aha.
So it's not enough to win the trade. A GM must be so far ahead of his peers that he also wins every trade in context, and a GM must be so far ahead of his peers that he wins every trade emphatically.
If Atkins can't win all of his trades EMPHATICALLY, IN CONTEXT, AND IN HINDSIGHT, then he might as well pick up his little balls and go home. Amirite?