No doubt he has been a great addition, but probably not some godsend?
Vlad - very close to career norms, no improvement
Kirk - is this just regression?
Bo - just healthy.
Ernie - exactly who he has been with Toronto, the whole tenure
Gimenez - flop.
Barger - tale of two halves at this point. Maybe people were celebrating his breakout too soon.
Heineman, Loperfido - BABIP says hi
That leaves Springer, Varsho, Straw, Lukes, Schneider
I don't know how much credit you give him for each of these guys. Springer is a grizzled veteran. Varsho is 28/29 and at the peak of his physical prime.
Like, people are probably overrating Popkins right now because of the team results (over-attribution error) and there were probably making the same mistake in the other direction for Guillermo Martinez before.
I am mostly pleased by the reports of the Trajekt and iPitch machines and Popkins wanting and implementing those. So not so much the results this year but just the information supporting the idea that the Jays are finally not behind the times on offensive game prep, which you can thank Popkins for at least in part.