Buck WAR/120G = 1.25
JPA WAR/120G = 0.75
JPA is 27 years old. He's not really a "prospect" / future / upside play anymore. He is what he is, and a case can be made that fWAR actually overrates him.
And then we can go back to the wonderfully factual overarching point that the Blue Jays never shouldve been pushed into "win now" mode to begin with.
AA made a bad decision to begin with, and then he confounded it by executing his ill advised course of action poorly.
I don't think Halladay ever said "Philly". He just wanted to get traded to a contender.
You could say similar things about Dickey. The deal was contingent on an extension, and he was only gonna sign one with certain teams.
To say that Anthopoulos didn't have any leverage is fallacious. He had the best pitcher in baseball to shop. That's plenty of leverage right there.
Just the value of the prospect package, in context.
i.e. the Jays paid more for old man Dickey than the Phillies paid for a *basically* prime Halladay.
I'm probably wrong though. I have no idea how highly regarded Taylor was.
I don't know. A small portion. But the ones that do tend to be pretty f***ing good. The lottery ticket has value.
d'Arnaud was the meat and potatoes of it anyway. Syndergaard was just a really nice looking side dish. He's grilled Zucchini.
As opposed to selling after the deadline? Probably.
It's a moot point though. Everyone except JJ is still here next year. They'll just chalk it up to "bad luck" or whatever, and give the ugly can another kick in 2014. Replacing Johnson with one of Hutch, Nolin. Or Sanchez in May, cuz Blue Jays.
I still think Dickey turns it around. Something is way off with the guy.
They don't even look like knuckleballs half the time... it's like he's just lobbing changeups in there all day.
RA Dickey is pitching barely better than replacement level.
We traded Travis d'Arnaud and Noah Syndergaard for him. That's a top ~20 position prospect and a top ~50 pitching prospect.
Syndergaard has a 2.35 FIP in A+ and is getting excellent reviews. He's striking out more hitters and walking less hitters than Aaron Sanchez is at the same level.
d'Arnaud is hurt right now, obviously, but Arencibia has a .299 wOBA and continues to be an arrogant, replacement level scrub.
Sad NJH is sad
At least Wojo's AAA promotion is off to a rocky start, Hech is hitting like a girl, Marisnick is whiffing a lot, and Hendo's arm exploded.
They could conceivably bring him back and give him a 90 pitch cap. I mean, why not? Desperation is the only sensible route at this point. They've backed themselves into this corner with no depth, now they need to do what they need to do. Too much invested in this season.
It's definitely a natural disagreement. You can tell that Dirk has only recently immersed himself into the world of sensible baseball statistics, but that's fine. He's getting better. I really like having him on the airwaves, the pregame and that Baseball Central thing.
I don't think it really perturbs Zaun either. He's the competitive jock type, so he probably likes to argue on the air, and in his mind he's always right so it doesn't really matter what Dirk says.
You know they would've passed on Giolito anyway.
I had a weird ass dream last night. My girlfriend was the Blue Jays GM, and we made the 10th overall pick at an A&W drive through. She wanted to pick someone I'd never heard of, and I was all mad about it, so we drove off and later found out that the scouting director picked Trey Ball. Then she turned into a chicken and the GM office flooded with two inches of water and the door wouldn't open. So the chicken GM girlfriend had to walk on it's tippy toes and it's chicken feet got all water logged and wrinkly. And Tinnish kept swimming down to slide paper under the door, because he wanted to keep the GM in the loop. And this happened in a school for some reason and there was a bike club which I was more concerned with than anything.
Seems kind of nuts that Frazier might actually be in the picture at #10.
He'll probably get popped at #9 by Pitt, just like Giolito got popped at #16 by the Nats last year.
Ceiling is basically Jon Jay. Maybe with a bet less defense (corner OF) and a bit more in terms of peripheral skills. We're talking about someone with a good hit tool, modest tools everywhere else, but enough instincts to make everything play up.
Martin Prado (the LF version) is another comp that comes to mind.
Relative to his peers, almost.
His wRC+ is at 211 right now.
Bonds broke the 200 mark 4 times during his peak. 212, 233, 234, and 244.
Now, obviously, Bonds did those over 4 full seasons and Miggy's # is only after ~45 games or so.
Daniel Norris figures something out.
May 13: 4 IP, 5 K, 3 BB, 0 HR, 1 H.
May 18: 4 IP, 7 K, 3 BB, 0 HR, 3 H.
Tonight: 4 IP, 10 K, 2 BB, 0 HR, 3 H.
1 run given up in his last 12 innings.
For the NA slot add? That's going to be May 31st now. I want it to be before the prospect cut down deadline, which is June 2nd at 11:59 PM EST. I'll add the NA slot on May 31st in the AM. Let's say 8 AM right on the nose. I'll set an alarm for it.
The prospect cut down date is June 2nd. It makes sense to add the NA slot just before that, so people can promote and stash a prospect if they want to juggle their roster that way. I'll push it through on the morning of Friday, May 31st.