Alright guys, here's the epic conclusion to my story:
I f***ED UP.
Attached the wrong PDF basically. I've never used printed tickets before through the Jays account manager... So what happened is I generated 2 different PDFs within 5 minutes of each other through my account manager, and attached the older PDF by accident. It really sucks because I knew about this possible problem, yet I still made the mistake. Kinda like when Justin Smoak knows a curveball in the dirt is coming, but still swings at it.
Anyways i'm happy to know that I wasn't being scammed, and that i'm just an idiot. I'll be able to regain the lost money through future game sales.
Bottom line: I'M AN IDIOT. Don't make the same mistake.
http://cdn.meme.am/instances/43231668.jpg
Let the insults flow