Not trying to find fault with this concept but what are you really basing this evaluation on? Is he the strongest/best player based on his ability to get on base and as such will be more effective as lead-off cuz others behind him (big hitters) will have a better opportunity to drive in more runs since he all be on base? Or, is he the strongest/best player based on his ability (big hitter) to drive in more runs with others on base before his turn at the plate? If so, having the 7th, 8th, and 9th hitters (weak players who will most probably never be walked and as such most probably never be on base when its his turn at the plate) coming before him every at-bat except the 1st inning seems inefficient. Or am I over-thinking this?