I don't know about Bautista. Edwin always looked really, really good when he was on.... on absolutely lost when he was off (like it was mental).
I only liked Yan Gomes because he was smashing the ball in spring training.... which can be pretty meaningless. I got the same type of excitement with Jim Negrych.
But as I think about Gomes now, in hindsight. The fact that he took up the game late as a kid.... the fact that he spent most of his college and minor league career as a backup...... he was always behind in AB's... and that meant something.