Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Community Moderator
Posted
5 minutes ago, bronson44 said:

 

Really nice for the Twins. I would have been really happy to give him that 

Posted
38 minutes ago, Laika said:

??? 

And if my aunt had wheels she'd be a bike 

What are we supposed to learn by saying "if this guy is worse than he should be"?

He's not comparable to Ernie like, at all. Garcia is a generally well rounded hitter who walks and hits the ball decently hard. Some batted ball profile issues. Like a mini Yandy Diaz. 

Ernie is a poof who never walks but makes elite contact and pulls everything in the air, he's super weird. 

There are reasons that MG has a full season 120 wRC+ on his resume. Someone like Ernie is physically and spiritually incapable of ever doing that

I'm just suggesting "what if he's the same as he was this year" because I don't put a lot of weight in projections.

Yes, MG and Clement have very different approaches at the plate - I'm just looking at results.  2025 Clement was a 97 wRC+ hitter who ran the bases well and played good defense.  That's all Garcia's ever been outside of 2025.  If MG is just a 100 wRC+ hitter, than he's very similar to 2025 Ernie Clement and I don't think that type of player carries a ton of value.  Perhaps Caleb Durbin and Bryson Stott are better comparable.

and MG was a 104 wRC+ hitter in AA/AAA as a 22 year old.  There isn't some elite minor league profile here.  He was a 117 wRC+ hitter in A/A+ as a 21 year old with a limp d*ck 0.114 ISO.  Apologies, but that doesn't get me erect either.

Don't get me wrong - MG, Durbin, Stott and 2025 Clement are all relatively valuable 2nd/3rd basemen.  I just don't think the league average bat with solid base running and good defense types carry an immense amount of trade value.

Posted
4 minutes ago, BTS said:

Really nice for the Twins. I would have been really happy to give him that 

Seems a bit odd that the Twins are spending.  I guess that's better than just watching 6-8 teams be willing to spend because the rest of the league figures there's no point...

Community Moderator
Posted
4 minutes ago, Brownie19 said:

Seems a bit odd that the Twins are spending.  I guess that's better than just watching 6-8 teams be willing to spend because the rest of the league figures there's no point...

Also odd that Gray wants to end his career missing the playoffs in Minnesota 

Posted
30 minutes ago, BTS said:

Really nice for the Twins. I would have been really happy to give him that 

Yeah I thought aside from Skubal that Gray was probably the best free agent rotation option that came without a qualifying offer. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Brownie19 said:

Seems a bit odd that the Twins are spending.  I guess that's better than just watching 6-8 teams be willing to spend because the rest of the league figures there's no point...

AL Central is also wide open. Twins have a shot contending if they make some additions this offseason. 

Posted
9 minutes ago, Terminator said:

Twins have a good rotation heading into next year.

  1. Joe Ryan
  2. Sonny Gray
  3. Taj Bradley
  4. Dean Kremer
  5. Bailey Ober
  6. IL: Pablo Lopez should be back early in the season, Festa could be out all year
  7. AAA: Kendrys Rojas, Mick Abel, Zebby Matthews, Connor Prielipp

Yeah deep rotation now and they have some interesting young arms. 

Really like Zebby and Connor. Think they could be breakout candidates in 2027. 

Posted
Just now, jaysblue said:

Yeah deep rotation now and they have some interesting young arms. 

Really like Zebby and Connor. Think they could be breakout candidates in 2027. 

Typical Twins team who will be good enough to compete for the AL Central and if they do manage to win it they'll get ass-blasted by the Yankees per usual

Posted
4 hours ago, Laika said:

Royals are insane to do this 

Seattle pitchers are Fool's Gold. 

Garcia doesn't even need fixing, who cares if he never hits 16 homers again, he's still a 26 year old good defensive 3B who makes contact and hits the ball hard on a sweet contract for four more seasons. That seems like a 3 WAR player regardless of power coming back.  Also a good baserunner. 

Miller is much more of a performance risk, he has had HR issues in recent years and has been destroyed on the road in his entire career. He projects worse and it's not even that close. He's also a freaking pitcher so watch him blow his elbow out. Ferrer should be a solid late relief option but that's not the kind of asset I would want to close the value gap. 

Yeah Maikel's floor is probably 3 WAR and he could play all over. If he returns to being a 110-120 wRC+ bat, he likely is a 4-5 WAR guy. 

Royals got some interesting arms. If they can get Miller to being a 2-3 WAR arm and Ferrer to be a 1-2 WAR reliever (or maybe closer). Not sure what Evans brings but he's still young. Looks like they value young and cheap controllable pitching. 

I probably prefer Garcia since his floor is higher. Royals have to work some more magic with Miller + Ferrer. 

Community Moderator
Posted
1 hour ago, Brownie19 said:

I'm just suggesting "what if he's the same as he was this year" because I don't put a lot of weight in projections.

Yes, MG and Clement have very different approaches at the plate - I'm just looking at results.  2025 Clement was a 97 wRC+ hitter who ran the bases well and played good defense.  That's all Garcia's ever been outside of 2025.  If MG is just a 100 wRC+ hitter, than he's very similar to 2025 Ernie Clement and I don't think that type of player carries a ton of value.  Perhaps Caleb Durbin and Bryson Stott are better comparable.

and MG was a 104 wRC+ hitter in AA/AAA as a 22 year old.  There isn't some elite minor league profile here.  He was a 117 wRC+ hitter in A/A+ as a 21 year old with a limp d*ck 0.114 ISO.  Apologies, but that doesn't get me erect either.

Don't get me wrong - MG, Durbin, Stott and 2025 Clement are all relatively valuable 2nd/3rd basemen.  I just don't think the league average bat with solid base running and good defense types carry an immense amount of trade value.

I don't know what you are trying to do but it seems stupid and over thought 

Durbin is good, just had a 3 win year and projects for the same. Garcia is good and had 1.8 WAR in just 80 games last year and projects well and he was a star the year prior 

The Red Sox paid a lot for Durbin 

Garcia's minor league stats from half a decade are are not relevant at all 

Ernie kind of sucks and was almost replacement level last year. He's not like them. 

Posted
10 minutes ago, Laika said:

I don't know what you are trying to do but it seems stupid and over thought 

Durbin is good, just had a 3 win year and projects for the same. Garcia is good and had 1.8 WAR in just 80 games last year and projects well and he was a star the year prior 

The Red Sox paid a lot for Durbin 

Garcia's minor league stats from half a decade are are not relevant at all 

Ernie kind of sucks and was almost replacement level last year. He's not like them. 

I'm kinda just talking out of my ass because there's nothing else to do.  Raps and Leafs below and the 2027 MLB season is probably going to be cancelled.  It's grim times so who cares.  I was just trying to lean into the board beliefs that guys who get a lot of their value from defense aren't actually worth as much as their WAR suggests.  The Varsho argument.  Durbin did have more value than I expected him too.  Maybe league average bats who play good defense are more valuable at 3rd base than they are in CF?

I brought up Garcia's minor league numbers because apparently I can't read.  I thought you said he had 120 wRC+ season in the minors.  I'm dumn.

Posted
6 hours ago, BTS said:

The Bobrovsky signing is the weirdest NHL deal in years. He looked washed last year at 37 and the team gives him 3 x7 for his age 38-40 seasons? Completely asinine 

Terrible.

Posted
2 hours ago, BTS said:

Also odd that Gray wants to end his career missing the playoffs in Minnesota 

Trade value, fellas. He'd be a target for a contender if need be.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...