OF

[Jimcanuck]

Who do you prefer among Kiermaier, Gallo, and Bellinger as a Jays OF signee.

[wilko]

If you're picking one of these guys to play everyday.. I'd go Bellinger and cross my fingers he figures it out. Platoon/4th OF? I'd go KK then Gallo.

[connorp]

Who do you prefer among Kiermaier, Gallo, and Bellinger as a Jays OF signee.

 

How do you not add Nimmo and none of the above

[Jimcanuck]

How do you not add Nimmo and none of the above

 

Because the debate has been regarding the other 3, dimwit

[wilko]

How do you not add Nimmo and none of the above

 

Because he's the clear #1

[connorp]

Because he's the clear #1

 

Really? I wouldn’t think so at all. If the poll was “who is the best of this group”, it would be different.

If you choose Nimmo, you would be assuming it’s a really big contract and so I would not pick Nimmo

[RobinThicc]

Dont waste money on any of these guys.

 

Re-sign Jackie Bradley Jr

[Deadpool]

Picked Belly, but Gallo would also intrigue me.

 

I think an old guy who gets most of his value from his legs is a sketchy investment (though, I wouldn't complain were he in the Zimmer role).

 

I don't think Nimmo fits in with the budget, unless you're not at all interested in signing the Vlads and Bos of the world.

[Krylian]

If those are my only options then I'm going with the guy with the highest upside. Belly

[max silver]

I wouldn't sign Gallo ahead of Bellinger or Kiermaier, but ultimately who to bring in would depend on what kind of money/term is required for the signing. If Kiermaier is attainable for significantly less than Bellinger he would be my choice.

[Jimcanuck]

I wouldn't sign Gallo ahead of Bellinger or Kiermaier, but ultimately who to bring in would depend on what kind of money/term is required for the signing. If Kiermaier is attainable for significantly less than Bellinger he would be my choice.

 

The intent is to vote in the poll "all else being equal"

[max silver]

The intent is to vote in the poll "all else being equal"

 

It's a tricky decision to say the least. I'd eliminate Gallo immediately as I wouldn't be surprised if he's finished as a productive offensive performer and he shouldn't be played in center field. Each of Kiermaier and Bellinger have plenty of question marks. KK had hip surgery, and it remains to be seen how he bounces back from the surgery. With close to full return of previous speed KK is by far the best defender of the trio. Bellinger has more potential with the bat, but I'm not overly convinced he will ever get past what he's shown the past two seasons falling in the .280 xWOBA range.

[The Cats Ass]

Ideally we trade Kirk for an ace defender like Jose Siri.

[Jimcanuck]

I think todd has hacked TCA's account

[connorp]

The intent is to vote in the poll "all else being equal"

 

Not very clear

[Omar]

Belly. If in doubt go with youth.

[Jonn]

Bellinger is the clear choice for me.

 

Gallo for a potential platoon scenario

 

Would not be happy if they signed Kiermaier.

[L54]

When Sperm wakes from his mid afternoon nap he’s going to have an aneurysm

[Jimcanuck]

When Sperm wakes from his mid afternoon nap he’s going to have an aneurysm

 

He will definitely need to take a time out, at minimum.

[FantasyNewb]

I'm currently at the gym, and if I read Kiermaier's name once more in the next half our, I'll punch the closest guy next to me. It makes me rage.

[Laika]

This poll is inversely related to their odds of signing in Toronto

[Sorrow]

I'd take Gallo but wouldn't be unhappy with any of the three. Gallo is one season removed from being a 4 win player.

[Funky]

Those are some pretty ugly choices. I do like Bellinger and hope he rebounds. He can hit from the left side of the plate and play good enough defense to move Springer over to right field. Possibly right field takes a little bit of wear and tear out a springer‘s legs?

 

When listening to Kershaw talk about the Dodgers last year, he had nothing but good things to say about Bellinger and a few of his other teammates seemed to agree. Could be a good thing for our bench after losing Teo.

[Spanky99]

None, Conforto.

[204Jays]

What about Grichuk lol?

[Spanky99]

The intent is to vote in the poll "all else being equal"

 

f*** your poll.

[Jimcanuck]

f*** your poll.

 

It stopped the Sperm's broken record.

[Terminator]

It stopped the Sperm's broken record.

 

Feel free to start however many polls you want Jim. I think I made point with my analogy in the other thread just fine.

 

And i don’t know if you guys are stalking me IRL now or what but Sperminator is actually what the guys at the bar call me lol. My friend Dave gave it to me after we found out I was going to be a father for the 7th time at age 59. What can I say? I’ve got some pretty potent stuff lmao

[Terminator]

When Sperm wakes from his mid afternoon nap he’s going to have an aneurysm

 

Ask your mom if she knows the Sperminator pal lol. You might be surprised at her answer lol

[wamco]

Term, I’m loving you volunteering extremely personal information unprovoked and doing so in a

Very comical fashion. Keep up the good work

Edited November 25, 2022 by wamco