Who's the better catcher?

youngtea · September 22, 2015

Russel Martin seems to be a way better catcher than Navarro or Thole. He knows how to manage the bullpen and what pitches will work.

Added poll to see how you all feel.

GD · September 22, 2015

err

L54 · September 22, 2015

Good luck.

BTS · September 22, 2015

IMO it's Martin

baubau · September 22, 2015

IMO it's Martin

What!? Noooo. Clearly its Navarro. You can't teach that pure hittin brah. Gibby said so.

guylaroche5 · September 22, 2015

lmao, I thought this was gonna be a McCann vs Martin debate but this one is much better

youngtea · September 22, 2015

Is there a stat that demonstrates ERA based on which catcher is catching?

King · September 22, 2015

Navarro, not close

Spanky__99 · September 22, 2015

Russel Martin seems to be a way better catcher than Navarro or Thole. He knows how to manage the bullpen and what pitches will work.

Added poll to see how you all feel.

This is obvious trolling, right, RIGHT?!?!

Rajais Mitten · September 22, 2015

Where is the JPA option #Top10Catcher

Spanky__99 · September 22, 2015

lmao, I thought this was gonna be a McCann vs Martin debate but this one is much better

Same.

Orgfiller · September 22, 2015

Is there a stat that demonstrates ERA based on which catcher is catching?

cERA, Mike Scioscia's go-to tool for evaluating catchers. Extremely effective.

L54 · September 22, 2015

lmao, I thought this was gonna be a McCann vs Martin debate but this one is much better

Lol I thought so too.

youngtea · September 22, 2015

Russel Martin is #12 in the leage in cERA:

http://espn.go.com/mlb/stats/fielding/_/position/c/sort/catcherERA/order/false

baubau · September 22, 2015

Russel Martin is #12 in the leage in cERA:

http://espn.go.com/mlb/stats/fielding/_/position/c/sort/catcherERA/order/false

That'll happen when you're catching Dickey and Walk-em Sanchez. I mean, he f***ing sucks! Should have traded for Cervelli from NYY instead.

TilsonBritoFan · September 22, 2015

Thole and its not even close

Stangstag · September 22, 2015

Brian McCann

GD · September 22, 2015

cERA, Mike Scioscia's go-to tool for evaluating catchers. Extremely effective.

why did you think this was a good idea

12 page essay single spaced due tomorrow

4.2k · September 22, 2015

Mods.

During the Gdt this account outed itself as a troll. Purge.

Cookie · September 22, 2015

this guy

http://i60.tinypic.com/sdfoxy.jpg

youngtea · September 22, 2015

Mods.

During the Gdt this account outed itself as a troll. Purge.

Troll. What part of what I said was trolling?

King · September 22, 2015

Mods.

During the Gdt this account outed itself as a troll. Purge.

That was lil looper

BigCecil · September 22, 2015

lmao, I thought this was gonna be a McCann vs Martin debate but this one is much better

Same thing I thought when I saw title and that it was a poll lol. It's some stellar trolling. If it was Martin or McCaan it would be a lot harder to answer.