Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[Deadpool]

Does anyone have any objections to moving this thread to Off Topic once the season starts? It's fine to be here while we're relatively dead, but this feels like an off-topic thread to me.

 

Thoughts?

[connorp]

Who f***ing cares, Achmed?!

 

Blow me, Gimpy. We’re about to do the redraft, so I was looking at how a draft went for the first time. Was curious where guys like Acuna, Tatis, DeGrom etc would go.

[Jimcanuck]

Blow me, Gimpy. We’re about to do the redraft, so I was looking at how a draft went for the first time. Was curious where guys like Acuna, Tatis, DeGrom etc would go.

 

pick in bbdl pls

[connorp]

pick in bbdl pls

 

I did bro?

[Jimcanuck]

I did bro?

 

good job

[Terminator]

Does anyone have any objections to moving this thread to Off Topic once the season starts? It's fine to be here while we're relatively dead, but this feels like an off-topic thread to me.

 

Thoughts?

 

I prefer it here on the main board.

[BTS]

I prefer it here on the main board.

 

Same. It gets more traffic here than it would in OT.

[L54]

I object to moving this thread

[Laika]

Does anyone have any objections to moving this thread to Off Topic once the season starts? It's fine to be here while we're relatively dead, but this feels like an off-topic thread to me.

 

Thoughts?

 

it's fine here

 

it's the bridge to off topic fantasy

[FantasyNewb]

Yeah, I agree to keep it on the main board.

 

If you had to choose between Moniak or Stott, who would you choose? Both are having great springs.

[Daniel Labude]

Yeah, I agree to keep it on the main board.

 

If you had to choose between Moniak or Stott, who would you choose? Both are having great springs.

 

Stott

[Laika]

Yeah, I agree to keep it on the main board.

 

If you had to choose between Moniak or Stott, who would you choose? Both are having great springs.

 

stott for sure

 

moniak is nothing

 

but honestly, neither

 

guarantee you can find better players

[FantasyNewb]

stott for sure

 

moniak is nothing

 

but honestly, neither

 

guarantee you can find better players

 

What about Miguel Vargas? Or is he in the same tier?

[Maine Jays]

20 team dynasty. I've held the #1 waiver spot for the past three seasons (it rolls over instead of resetting) waiting for the perfect add. The only time I was tempted before now was Deivi Garcia a couple years ago, but now Asa Lacy has been cut. Was last year just an enigma or did the Royals waste the #4 pick on a RP?

[TwistedLogic]

Made this trade a few minutes ago. Thoughts?

 

 

Not a keeper/dynasty, just a regular H2H Weekly league.

[Laika]

Made this trade a few minutes ago. Thoughts?

 

 

Not a keeper/dynasty, just a regular H2H Weekly league.

 

probably good in a redraft

 

you don't want to waste a roster spot on underperforming prospects for too long

[BTS]

Made this trade a few minutes ago. Thoughts?

 

 

Not a keeper/dynasty, just a regular H2H Weekly league.

 

Love that in a redraft

[Laika]

wait WTF you got Semien for him? hahahaha I was reading that as Marcus Stroman and still thought it was good

[Daniel Labude]

Made this trade a few minutes ago. Thoughts?

 

 

Not a keeper/dynasty, just a regular H2H Weekly league.

 

Id have probably stuck with Julio, even just for this year

[Laika]

In a standard 5x5, 12 team league Semien would be worth about $13 and J Rod projects to be worth around $2. By steamer.

 

By The Bat it's $16 and $2

[TwistedLogic]

Yeah lol, the only thing I'm iffy about is if I really needed Semien with my middle infield depth.

 

That said, I was pretty strong at OF as well.

 

Here's my roster:

 

 

And the scoring rules:

 

[Spanky99]

Made this trade a few minutes ago. Thoughts?

 

 

Not a keeper/dynasty, just a regular H2H Weekly league.

 

Hah! You did very well, friendo.

[Spanky99]

Id have probably stuck with Julio, even just for this year

 

In a redraft?

[Laika]

Yeah lol, the only thing I'm iffy about is if I really needed Semien with my middle infield depth.

 

That said, I was pretty strong at OF as well.

 

Here's my roster:

 

 

And the scoring rules:

 

 

Semien kind of completes that offense tbh

[jaysblue]

Semien over J-Rod in a non-dynasty for sure!

[Daniel Labude]

In a redraft?

 

Yeah, I think he comes on strong after an adjustment period

[Spanky99]

Yeah, I think he comes on strong after an adjustment period

 

Over Semien?

[Daniel Labude]

Over Semien?

 

Yeah. I think Semien takes a step back. Bit of a risk, but I would gamble on JRod

[jaysblue]

Over Semien?

 

I see Semien hitting .240/.250ish with 30HR and 80-90 RBI with around 10SB and a .780-.790 OPS this season. Still for a 2B/SS eligible bat, I take him over J-Rod in a redraft league. Unless J-Rod goes all Ryan Braun in his rookie year.

[L54]

20 team dynasty. I've held the #1 waiver spot for the past three seasons (it rolls over instead of resetting) waiting for the perfect add. The only time I was tempted before now was Deivi Garcia a couple years ago, but now Asa Lacy has been cut. Was last year just an enigma or did the Royals waste the #4 pick on a RP?

 

I’m late but don’t use #1 waiver on Asa Lacy