Jump to content
Join our multi-site All-Star Game thread, click here! ×
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

P2F

By P2F
in Fantasy Sports

 Share

Recommended Posts

BTS GOAT

BTS

Community Moderator
Posted
Posted
I have to choose between Marco Gonzales and Forrest Whitley. My team is weak on pitching so Marco would actually be an upgrade for this year, but is there any chance Whitley can still turn into a frontline starter?

 

Forrest Whitley is a non-prospect in most formats. Feels like you can flip Gonzales for someone better unless it’s a 10-team league with keeper limits or something.

  • Replies 3.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

BTS
BTS

Two-team dynasty is an interesting format. 

Jimcanuck
Jimcanuck

He dealt with injuries for much of 2024.  Then was healthy for AFL and had an OPS of .970.  As an 18 yr old playing against guys 3 to 4 yrs older. Age / level is important.  He will likely play m

Abomination
Abomination

How sure are people that Roki would be the target? The top is stacked this year.  I think I would probably keep Langford, but that's a very interesting proposal.

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
Ok, thanks. Yeah, like I said my pitching is s***. Hitting is great. So Marco is an upgrade on the back end of my rotation. I could probably get Whitley later in the draft anyway.
FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
Just got an offer of Winker for Rodon. I have Kelenic, Alvarez, Carlson, and Brennan Davis for OF. Rodon is a part of my starting 7 and I don't have anyone else to replace him at the moment. Is the Winker upgrade in OF worth giving up Rodon and trying to find a starter in the draft?
Jimcanuck Buffalo Bisons

Jimcanuck

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Posted
Just got an offer of Winker for Rodon. I have Kelenic, Alvarez, Carlson, and Brennan Davis for OF. Rodon is a part of my starting 7 and I don't have anyone else to replace him at the moment. Is the Winker upgrade in OF worth giving up Rodon and trying to find a starter in the draft?

 

Brennan won't debut until 2023, most likely. Rodon is a pitch away from being out of baseball.

 

I would do that deal, get a starter in the draft, as a last resort you can stream free agent starters as your 7th

 

Do you have to drop someone to add Winker and whoever you get as the new 7th starter?

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
Brennan won't debut until 2023, most likely. Rodon is a pitch away from being out of baseball.

 

I would do that deal, get a starter in the draft, as a last resort you can stream free agent starters as your 7th

 

Do you have to drop someone to add Winker and whoever you get as the new 7th starter?

 

Hey, I wouldn't have to drop anyone to get Winker. I still have Dustin May and Grayson Rodriguez to step in as my future 7th starter. I think Eovaldi will be available in the draft as well so he can help me this year, until they step in.

Carlos Danger Dunedin Blue Jays

Carlos Danger

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Posted
Just got an offer of Winker for Rodon. I have Kelenic, Alvarez, Carlson, and Brennan Davis for OF. Rodon is a part of my starting 7 and I don't have anyone else to replace him at the moment. Is the Winker upgrade in OF worth giving up Rodon and trying to find a starter in the draft?

 

Would grab Winker in a heartbeat!

Spanky__99 FCL Blue Jays

Spanky__99

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Posted
Yeah Winker is the better asset. I'd do it.

 

Far better, with far less risk. Kind of a no-brainer, I think. When a team doesn't offer up a QO that's a pretty big red flag.

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
If you could do an upgrade of Yoan Moncada to Bregman (with multiple pieces being added with Monaca), or an upgrade of McCullers to Aaron Nola (with multiple pieces being added with McCullers) what would you choose? This is a points league.
Laika Cooperstown

Laika

Community Moderator
Posted
Posted
If you could do an upgrade of Yoan Moncada to Bregman (with multiple pieces being added with Monaca), or an upgrade of McCullers to Aaron Nola (with multiple pieces being added with McCullers) what would you choose? This is a points league.

 

neither

 

but bregman for sure if i had to

Laika Cooperstown

Laika

Community Moderator
Posted
Posted
Thanks.

 

Is Paddack worth anything at this point? I have to pick him or Hancock as the drop off date is tomorrow.

 

Personally I'd still roll with Paddack.

 

1. Can help you this year

2. Decent chance he is actually good and has been running into some bad luck on homers or batted balls

3. Decent chance even if he has run problems he is one tweak away from being amazing

4. Hancock has a pretty s***** k rate in the minors as far as prospects go.

 

I don't remember it both are fully healthy so that is part of the decision

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
neither

 

but bregman for sure if i had to

 

I'm guessing you wouldn't pick either due to the multiple pieces? I mean Bregman is an upgrade to Moncada and Nola is an upgrade to McCullers? No?

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
Personally I'd still roll with Paddack.

 

1. Can help you this year

2. Decent chance he is actually good and has been running into some bad luck on homers or batted balls

3. Decent chance even if he has run problems he is one tweak away from being amazing

4. Hancock has a pretty s***** k rate in the minors as far as prospects go.

 

I don't remember it both are fully healthy so that is part of the decision

 

Thanks. I kept Paddack, hoping for a bounceback. Plus, this league doesn't place much value on prospects. I think Hancock could easily drop to where I can pick him up in the draft.

Laika Cooperstown

Laika

Community Moderator
Posted
Posted
I'm guessing you wouldn't pick either due to the multiple pieces? I mean Bregman is an upgrade to Moncada and Nola is an upgrade to McCullers? No?

 

Yeah I just was assuming you would not get good value trading for either

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted

Ok, thanks.

 

One last question for probably a while. I have Noevi Marte and have both Bogaerts and Witt Jr. for SS. I only have Gurriel Jr., who can cover 1st. Would you trade Marte for Andrew Vaughan straight up? I assume he'll transition to 1st full time when Abreau is done. Is the trade worth it? Again, this is a points league.

FantasyNewb College Ball

FantasyNewb

Verified Member
Posted
Posted
I'm curious as to where they'll play Witt Jr in the next couple of years. I need a 3rd base and was going to try and trade for Bregman but I heard that Witt Jr. is playing for the 3rd base job in spring. Do you think he'll get 10 games/yr going forward to keep the 3rd base eligibility?
Daniel Labude Toronto Blue Jays

Daniel Labude

Jays Centre Contributor
Posted
Posted
I'm guessing you wouldn't pick either due to the multiple pieces? I mean Bregman is an upgrade to Moncada and Nola is an upgrade to McCullers? No?

 

Moncada > Bregman

Laika Cooperstown

Laika

Community Moderator
Posted
Posted
I'm curious as to where they'll play Witt Jr in the next couple of years. I need a 3rd base and was going to try and trade for Bregman but I heard that Witt Jr. is playing for the 3rd base job in spring. Do you think he'll get 10 games/yr going forward to keep the 3rd base eligibility?

 

I dunno. He might as a rookie but if things go to plan Witt is just playing SS everyday, forever.

Daniel Labude Toronto Blue Jays

Daniel Labude

Jays Centre Contributor
Posted
Posted
How come? I see that quite differently.

 

Bregman was propped up by a the juiced ball and crappy stadium. I see him in the .260 20 HR range which i think is Moncadas floor. A bad time with covid set Moncada back, so now a year or so out from it he could breakout again. Lots of walks as well for Moncada

Spanky__99 FCL Blue Jays

Spanky__99

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Posted
Bregman was propped up by a the juiced ball and crappy stadium. I see him in the .260 20 HR range which i think is Moncadas floor. A bad time with covid set Moncada back, so now a year or so out from it he could breakout again. Lots of walks as well for Moncada

 

So you're just going to ignore what Bregman has done, it's superior to Moncada. Moncada has broken out by the way.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

Become a Caretaker

  • Member Statistics

    21,010
    Total Members
    48,845
    Most Online
    Taylor Leonard
    Newest Member
    Taylor Leonard
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...