I don't remember enough from that draft, and you could be right in your analysis. I just remember wanting Sale (I know, hindsight) and my vague recollection of McGuire's scouting report was that of a bland, back of the rotation guy, Jays selected to move quickly to the majors.
McGreevy at least seems to be a little younger, better athlete (?) and under the current Jays development system, perhaps still has room to grow. If Jays were picking 11 as in 2010, then yes, I would hope for higher upside. But at 19, if McGreevy can develop into a mid-rotation guy, maybe a no.3, I wouldn't mind I don't think.