Hutch has had MINIMAL success at the MLB level and one might argue that without the offensive support behind him last year, his W-L numbers are completely reversed to go along with the rest of his horrid numbers.
Aside from a high walk rate, Sanchez actually had minimal success in the same role as well. But I gotta say that Sanchez has pitched his way into a job and its his to lose. If he keeps his walk rate down, all this BS about missing bats and all that is completely meaningless as long as he continues to induce weak contact on the ground. It's when he tries to do too much that he gets himself into trouble. His natural ability is more than enough to carry him as a number 2 or 3 guy, depending on what kind of makeup he has mentally.
A lot of that that is yet to be seen and that is the plain and simple truth. So people judging that a 22 year old is this or that has no f***ing idea what they are talking about. He could be a complete bust or he could end up being a solid no 2 guy. Could end up being a valuable back end of the bullpen guy as he's proven to be over the past 2 seasons.
But my take is that he has above average MLB stuff. Needs to develop his secondary pitches and above all else, we need to find out where his composure level on that mound is at over a generous period of time. Then make some sort of solid judgement on what he actually is. Until then, all this hate on a 22 year old kid with a 96 plus fastball with movement is just worthless. His ceiling is obviously pretty high, so why not find out how high that ceiling goes?