The reality is if he leaves Anderson in and he gives up a blooper and then a 3 run HR - most would bitch that he left him in too long. Like it or not, we are in a era where marginal starters (like Anderson) don't face lineups a 3rd time - primarily because the numbers suggest it's a terrible idea.
In hindsight, he should have left Anderson in - and I'd fully support if he left Ryu and Roark in a bit too long also, while simply stating to the public that his bullpen is taxed right now and he had to get more innings out of his starters - even if it comes with diminishing results.
The Jays need to mix in a few blowouts to help the cause. We are playing a s*** ton of close games right now.