Sure, if the Jays were in the race right now, then it would be a good time to be a buyer. It's clearly a bad time to be a seller of struggling vets (if there is ever a good time). I just want there to be some upside to either trading the player or keeping him, and that's even more important if the Jays want to go for another run next season because assets are movable. Say what you want about Harold Ramirez and Reese McGuire, but you can move those guys if need be. Quantity can be an asset for a farm system, as long as it's not at the expense of quality. If the Jays got Sparkman for Liriano, and then Sparkman turns into even a middle reliever, that's an asset. It's worth something, even if very little. But letting Liriano and Estrada go for nothing, while a perfectly likely scenario with how the market has played out this deadline and how bad both players have been, would be pretty disappointing all things considered. It wouldn't be the end of the world if they left for nothing, but I'm in the camp of "something is better than nothing".