Good choice by the voters not succumbing to statistical noise. JD has more doubles, same amount of HR's, and struck out less leading to more opportunities to help his team score. Doesn't even count the production type numbers, which he was insane in (yes I know, lineup is better). Pretty much park factor is all that saves Trout in the stuff you guys are looking at (wrc+), but most of JD's home runs were no doubters.
I see these two are virtually a tie, so a better story should give it to JD