Those 2 are big holes to fill but so far this year they have provided only 3.3 WAR in 2 roster spots and we have 50 wins at the AS Break. With the money we would save in not signing them there is room to backfill that loss. I see 3 years as the max risk we could take on them, and even that scares the hell out of me with their expected AAV. Have to say though that if Jose doesn't come back with a vengeance, his value will drop big time. DL/lost production/age = risk
The big argument for a 5 year deal some were making was how well he kept himself in shape and that that would allow him to beat aging curves. The guy has had hip, shoulder and now toe issues of all things.