Obviously this is a topic that has been discussed to death on here, but I'm still left wondering what the team could have looked like without these two trades. No matter who you think was at fault for the trades, they definitely came as a result of Rogers being willing to increase payroll. Whether they always were willing to, or they all of a sudden decided to last year, we might never know. Here's the idea I've been playing with:
Rogers decides to keep the status quo payroll for 2013, and delays the payroll bump for one year. So this off-season, Alex gets the go ahead to jack up the payroll to 136M (Wendy Thurm's estimated opening day 2014 number).
My best guess for end of 2013 roster with 2014 contract numbers from Cot's. This is assuming that all other moves still happen (Melky, Happ, Esmil Rogers, etc.)
C - D'Arnaud 500k
1B - Encarnacion 9M
2B - Hechavarria 500K? (contract up, pre-arb eligible)
3B - Lawrie 500k
SS - Escobar 5M
LF - Cabrera 8M
CF - Rasmus 7M
RF - Bautista 14M
DH - Lind 7M
Bench
OF - Gose 500K
2B/3B - Izturis 3M
C - Mathis 1.5M
SS/2B - Kawasaki 1M
SP - Morrow 8M
SP - Alvarez 500K
SP - Happ 5.4M
SP - Rogers 1.85M
SP - Redmond 500K
BP - Janssen 4M
BP - Santos 3.75M
BP - McGowan 1.5M
BP - Cecil 1.5M
BP - Perez 500K
BP - Delabar 500K
BP - Loup 500K
BP - Jeffress 500K
This gives us 86.5M + Romero 7.5M = 94M meaning 42M (!) to improve the team. Obviously the rotation is putrid for the hypothetical 2014 season, 2B is still a glaring hole, Lind needs a platoon partner, etc.
What would you do to improve the team for 2014 and beyond?
TL;DR They blew it.