He was in the middle of the packish with "meh" type players. May not be the best argument for him. It was a great idea! I would have never thought of looking at production on non-contact PA like that. The most amazing thing I found from that was Albert Pujols was a destructive tank back in his day. Would be a great article on Bau and Eddy and potentially JD if you look at it year by year.
This is what I have now. I removed the "why has he not performed" part. Unless someone has anything else they'd like to mention, I'll post it:
Can He Really Smoak It?
Originally noticed by scouts whom were initially looking at his teammate and friend, Matt Wieters, Justin Smoak became a top 5 rated talent in the 2008 draft due to his ability to hit and hit for power. Taken 11th overall by the Rangers, Smoak continued to impress in the minors with his bat, being ranked by Baseball America in the Ranger’s organization in having best power, best strike zone discipline and best hitter for average. He was so highly regarded he was the main piece in the Cliff Lee trade from Seattle to Texas.
Looking at his Major League career so far, it has been a disappointment in terms of his ability. Some could be wondering, where did his ability to hit and hit for power go? In actuality it may have not gone anywhere. The overall popular stats used by many such as batting average does not reflect well on Smoak, career .224 hitter, however the advanced statistics show a different story.
Hard% measures how hard the ball has been hit and while there is no guarantee that a hard hit bill will fall for a hit, it is more likely to than not. Over the past 5 years, Smoak’s Hard% has increased.
2011 – 28.2%
2012 – 28.9%
2013 – 36.6%
2014 – 36.4%
2015 – 37.3%
In 2015, for players with at least 200 PA, his Hard% is good for 27th in the league, ahead of bashers Nelson Cruz, Prince Fielder, Tood Frazier, Joey Votto and teammates Josh Donaldson and Jose Bautista.
Smoak batted ball distance has also increased each year since 2011:
http://cdn.fangraphs.com/fantasy/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Justin-Smoak-Distance-Trend.png
Image per fangraphs.
Smoak also has not lost his plate discipline. He has a relatively high strikeout at a career 22.7% K, to be expected from a power hitter, but he also has a respectable walk rate at a career 10.6% BB.
For his career his 0-Swing% has been 27.5% and steadily declined over the past 3 years.
2013 – 29.2%
2014 – 27.8%
2015 – 25.2%
He is chasing less pitches outside the zone, but mind you there is understandably some discrepancy in this data as in 2013 he had nearly twice as many PA as 2014 and 2015.
While playing the majority of his career at Safeco Fields, a pitcher friendly ball park, Smoak has met or outperformed his xHR vs actual HR.
2010: 17.5 xHR | 13 HR
2011: 16 xHR | 16 HR
2012: 16.3 xHR | 18 HR
2013: 18 xHR | 20 HR
2014: 7 xHR | 7 HR
*stats per baseballheatmaps xHR, HR
Smoak’s defense has also brought value to a team whose previous 1st basement were a tandem of Edwin Encarnacion and Adam Lind, both of whom are rated below average to awful. While he may still split duties with Edwin, he has been brought in as a pinch defender late in the games often for the Jays. Among 1B with at least 200 PA, Smoak ranks tied for 5th at Defense (Def) at -2.3. His Ultimate Zone Rating (UZR) rates him as an average defender at 2.1, however his UZR/150, UZR scaled to an average number of chances for a season, has him as an above average defender at 7.2. He has rated so well his defensive metrics are ahead of renowned gold glove winners Eric Hosmer, Adrian Gonzalez and Mark Teixeira.
Justin can Smoak it. There is still potential in his bat and while he may never win the batting championship he can provide 10-20 HRs over a season while playing great defense at 1B. There is value in that.