They can't. Danny Jansen has been so bad that they would feel guilty doing so. They are desperately trying to trade Reese. Jansen should be grateful he is the Ryu Whisperer.
I mean losing the glove and the one other pitch last night was a bad look on Reese last night, but his framing statistics this year are slightly better than Jansen this year. Go back over the last couple years and Jansen might be a tick better, but they both frame reasonably well. McGuire has thrown out runners much better this year than Jansen. His bat has been better. I think Jansen calls a better game, but that's hard to quantify.
We have 2 back up catchers. We need to get rid of one. Most on here would get rid of Mcguire as if it's a no brainer. I've lost some patience with Jansen. Athletically he should be the better, but how long do you have to wait for a kid to put things together. If someone wanted Jansen in a trade over Mcguire I'd get rid of Jansen.
Our best catcher is Kirk and he's on a 7 game hitting streak after playing 7 games in AAA. He needs to be up with the Jays.