This is my conspiracy theory for the night. AA was taken over by Rogers Corporation, and is now their puppet. Rogers Corporation doesn't care about what is best for the team. They only care about making money and building the brand. Here is some of my proof.
I think it started back last years trade deadline. When he traded for JA Happ. AA was told he had to make a deal for a name, to make a deal with a ton of players, just to make the headlines. Especially since they weren't doing all that great on the season. Just think of how much the Toronto Bluejays where in the news when they made their (9?) player trade.
Next came the Marlins deal.. Oh the names we picked up in that deal. Has there ever been so many names acquired by one team in one deal. A deal that'll be talked about for years and years, but not just us but by all baseball fans...
Then there was the Dickey. What would be the best way to end the off season? Trade for an award winner of course. We needed a pitcher, may as well get last years CY Young award winner. At any means necessary, even if it would take our top 2 prospects. AA's hands were tied.
And the 4th reason is... No GM would be insane enough to employ JP Arenciba as a starting catcher. Rogers Corporation needs JPA around to bring in all the teenage girls. And then they sell a phone to them while they're at it.