He's still young though he isn't one of the top shortstops offensively to own in fantasy as you would have thought when you dropped his name. Has a .750 OPS with only 6 HR's and 9 SB's this season thus far. I don't see him posting better numbers than 2015 or 2016 moving forward.
Tim Beckham would have been a nice addition to this club. I don't think the O's paid a huge price if I'm not mistaken. Would have been a significant upgrade over either Goins or Barney right now and he's the type of guy you can keep around for next season as a third MI to rotate between Tulo & Travis. Has posted a 1.3 WAR so far this season and would be under control until 2021.
If Yankees have a full rotation that is healthy and 100%, I would have Gray behind Severino, Tanaka, and Pineda. Gray is a solid pitcher, though on a team with World Series aspirations, he's likely a No. 3 at best.
If Morales is still with the team in 2018, Pearce likely is the everyday LF I would imagine (unless he's traded). If Morales is moved, Pearce would become the everyday DH.
He's arb eligible, but yeah I don't see the Jays paying him $6 million through arbitration. Likely will decline arbitration on him and agree to a less $ figure.
Knowing how Shapiro and Atkins work, they like to have potential roster holes filled in advance in case they strike out in the offseason. For e.g. re-signing Justin Smoak last August. With LF being a major hole on this team and with Bautista leaving, they figured Aoki at least covers a corner OF spot at a decent price in case they can't make a bigger upgrade earlier in the offseason.
Sign JD Martinez to play RF. Trade for Ian Kinsler to play 2B. Trade for Robbie Grossman to play LF and to DH occasionally. Trade Morales and get rid of his ass which will open up the DH spot for Steve Pearce. Boom!
I think Smith is a guy they can get value for and should be moved, no questions asked. As for Liriano and Estrada, if you can't get anything for them, the Jays are just better to keep them when you consider how thin the rotation is right now. Plus you can evaluate them more over the last two months in case you bring one of them back on a cheap one-year deal.