B
I wouldn't give them an A. For those posters who did, clearly they're being homers.
I think the Jays improved nicely without giving up much in terms of prospect capital. I think Bass and Pop were solid additions to the bullpen. Mitch White is a solid No 4/5 starter who is under control and gives the Jays some depth if a starter goes down to injury or if Kikuchi implodes again. I do like Whitt Merrifield. He has been a consistent 3-4 WAR player who I think will benefit from a change of scenery and I think his speed in the Postseason will be a difference maker. Plus he's under control again in 2023 at a very reasonable salary that doesn't break the bank.
What keeps me from giving the Blue Jays an A? Well like CarlosDanger said earlier and made a valid point, a lot of the Jays competition did get better and acquired some better pieces. As well, I think we all would have loved to have seen the Blue Jays trade for a real impact guy like a Carlos Rodon to really bolster the rotation in the Postseason. Imagine going into a series with Gausman, Manoah and Rodon + Berrios as a No. 4. I think acquiring a SP like Rodon would have made the Blue Jays a more dangerous team in a short series and given them a better chance against another top team. Lastly, I think another BP arm would have been nice, someone with a high K% and late inning experience. You can never have enough pitching down the stretch and in the Postseason.
Though another factor was the vaccine requirements to enter Canada. Maybe guys like Castillo, Rodon, Cobb or other relievers or players couldn't come here and weren't willing to get the vax afterwards which made things a lot tougher for Atkins. So I would give him the benefit of the doubt if that was the case.