Yeah I agree with your points. I don't place entire blame on Atkins and the front office for everything that happens on the field. Majority of the blame should be placed on the players such as Vlad, Manoah, Kirk, Varsho, Springer, Chapman, Espy, Cimber, Bass etc. for heavily underperforming. I've stated that numerous times. Still that's a lot of players underperforming all at the same time, so I do believe that the front office should own some of it. They're the ones putting this roster together at the end of the day, so you have to then question those projected performances when most don't play to those expectations. I'm sure Atkins would be the first person to say that as well. But yes, I do acknowledge everything shouldn't be blamed on Atkins. He's built competitive teams every season which is excellent and kudos to him. Hope we can see this team take it to the next level in the Postseason this year or in 2024.
As for the coaching staff, same thing. Don't place 100% of the blame on them, but when a most of the Jays bats aren't hitting for the power they're capable of and hitting a ton of ground balls, you have to start questioning the approach being taken and why haven't certain adjustments been made. That's on some of the coaching staff, but at the end of the day solely on the players.
It's great to finally see some guys in the upper minors getting called up and actually contributing. I know it sucks because it's at the expense of Bo and Chapman being injured. If the Jays make the Postseason, guys like Schneider, Clement, Genesis, Horwitz etc. definitely played huge roles in helping the team get there. Small sample sizes but still can't complain on the job they're all doing thus far. Will praise Atkins on that, even if a bit of luck is involved. Kind of wish guys like Schneider/Clement were called up a bit earlier to replace Biggio/Espinal but oh well.
Like you said, there's all kinds of variables at play. Can't just place blame on one entity entirely. You're always going to have trolls post in the GDT's or call in on radio shows where they call for Atkins or Schneider being fired for losing one game. I'm sure it happens in every city haha. Unfortunately if the Jays don't win a World Series in the next three seasons, Atkins and company, along with the coaching staff are likely gone. That's how it goes, even if it's not entirely their faults. Let's just hope this team gets into the postseason and with this pitching staff, gotta like their chances to go on a run. Hopefully one or two big bats could come alive, which would be a huge plus.