Someone always cheats and ruins these in the first post, but I'll give you a real guess. Backup catchers and shortstops immediately come to mind.
I'm going to say Alfredo Griffin, who would have played, had Joe Carter not hit his iconic home run. Then I'll say Dick Schofield for the 93 team.
For catchers, I'll say Randy Knorr for one of those years and go with a reliever in Danny Cox as my final guess.