Their prep sheets, reports and whatever else they bring really shouldn't differ that much from what Fangraphs says anyhow. It doesn't take a former big leaguer to realize that pitching to Simmons last night was most likely the worst possible match up the Jays could have put out there.
Sorry to beat a dead horse, but I don't mind ripping on the guy when he's in the wrong. He shouldn't be immune to the criticism he's receiving. I don't blame the loss on Gibby, because there were a lot of other things that went wrong. What I blame is the process- one that clearly wasn't thought out, or they were unprepared for.