IMPORTANT CHANGES TO MINOR LEAGUE ROSTER MANAGEMENT AND ASSOCIATED RULES
Background:
- In Yahoo we did not allow prospect demotions. The main reason being it would have been a pain to ask the commissioners to process them.
- In Yahoo any player who played in AA the year prior could be added. With no demotions and one NA slot the effect of this was that a small number of near-MLB prospects would be owned in Yahoo.
- In Yahoo we used mandatory prospect promotion thresholds. The initial theory was to prevent prospect hoarding by good teams and to promote turnover/transactions. The main effect seemed to just be the rare punitive effect on an owner who forgot to promote.
New Substrate:
- Fantrax opens up easy movement of players to the minors, allowing demotions.
- Demotions would clash with our AA eligibility rule, allowing any team to stuff their minor league roster with decent prospects from free agency.
- The mandatory prospect promotion thresholds don't seem to really matter. Teams will probably promote or trade good prospects and cut bad ones naturally.
New Rules:
- We will have unregulated promotion and demotion from/to the MiLB roster (in Fantrax you can't demote unless they have a green flag; in Fantrax if an MiLB player loses their flag it does not lock your roster).
- Waiver draft eligibility will be changed to only include prospects who played in AAA in the previous year (or a prior year).
- Free agent eligibility will be changed to only include players with MLB service time. Players making their debut will be eligible to be added at 8PM EST on the day following their first active day on the 25 man roster. If desired, an owner can request before the 8PM EST eligibility time that a commissioner place a debuting player on "debut waivers." A commissioner who places a player on debut waivers has to announce it in this thread. There is no general obligation to use debut waivers, which is an accommodation for owners who can't compete for an 8PM EST add, but there is an obligation for commissioners to respond to requests for debut waivers.
- The mandatory prospect promotion thresholds will be no more.
- I had previously added a 13th MiLB slot to replace the NA slot. I have decided to reduce the MiLB slots to 12 again in light of all of this.
I think all of this is sensible but I am still open to comments, particularly about the debut waivers thing.