It's hard to tell how much of Cleveland's drafting post 2010 was more Antonetti's or Shapiro's responsibility. However, while he was the GM when Kipnis was picked in 2009, the other players who made it? Tony Sipp, Vinnie Pestano, Cody Allen, Jeremy Guthrie, Lonnie Chisenhall, Kevin Kouzmanoff, Josh Tomlin, TJ House, and Zach Putnam. Not very strong.
His trades were stronger than his draft record, IMO.