I'd vote for him. He performed like one of the best pitchers ever, and had the kind of personality that the game doesn't have nearly enough of. The HoF is about recognizing th greats, and in the games that he played, he was on that level. I don't care what might have happened if his career hadn't ended at 24, because the innings he did throw were HOF calibre. Also, the hall takes itself far too seriously if it can't consider including someone like this out of resepect.