Some people will think it's too much. Some won't. The bottom line is that the punishment has to actually sting. A 2nd rounder for a team that owns three 1sts doesn't. Dinger's very late 1st (the 3rd pick jaysblue has in the draft) is far from crippling, but it's enough to hurt. The intent here is to set a precedent of significant repercussions in order to deter owners from being careless about this type of thing. It's not something that should happen.