Blue Jays (Cease) vs Athletics (Lopez): 09/07/26, 10:05 PM

[Spanky__99]

Attaboy Kirky! Jays in flight!

[Omar]

And we're back!

[Smokinitup420]

And he made up for his stupidity 

[Olerud363.354]

1 minute ago, hanton said:

You're correct there's a rule on that - would have to look it up

what is the rule on that?  could they have challenged and they didn't ?  Or you can't challenge in that situation?

[Omar]

Just now, Olerud363.354 said:

what is the rule on that?  could they have challenged and they didn't ?  Or you can't challenge in that situation?

Two seconds to challenge. 

[Olerud363.354]

1 minute ago, Omar said:

Two seconds to challenge. 

But how do you do that when you throw to second then have to join the rundown?  Like just tap your hat after the throw?

[Omar]

ALERT!  Lukes gets a hit off a lefty.

[Jays24]

Ernie continues his useless 2nd half.  Would have taken a bunt from him there considering how bad hes been.  

[JaysFan99]

I love Ernie, but he has so many unproductive infield pop ups. At least he saw more than 1 pitch.

[Omar]

Need a Straw base hit.

[hanton]

I'm fairly certain the ABS challenge can be made immediately after that play, for sure on a throw down to 2nd during a steal

[Spanky__99]

2nd inning man

Why challenge?

[Omar]

Ump f***ing us.

[Jays24]

Pathetic offense continues to be pathetic.  Team needs to upgrade Ernie next year to make him a super sub.  

[hanton]

3 minutes ago, Olerud363.354 said:

But how do you do that when you throw to second then have to join the rundown?  Like just tap your hat after the throw?

I pretty sure the window to challenge is extended until that play is over, Kirk could then turn to the ump and challenge - has to be done immediately.  

[Olerud363.354]

Oh wow.  2 guys on the Clement, Giminez, Straw.  Why is McAdoo not playing?  I guess he isn't that great. 

The entire thing with Davis Schneider just blows.  I guess he really can't hit this year.  .207 this year at Buffalo.\

 

 

[Masterbather]

Just now, Spanky__99 said:

2nd inning man

Why challenge?

At least it's a leverage situation. Not like most of the time when they challenge in the stupidest situations.

[Jays24]

Just now, Omar said:

Ump f***ing us.

Or the player can learn to challenge the calls properly.  

[Smokinitup420]

Id rather see McAdoo get some playing time , clement is useless right now give him a week off 

[Olerud363.354]

Just now, hanton said:

I pretty sure the window to challenge is extended until that play is over, Kirk could then turn to the ump and challenge - has to be done immediately.  

So basically Kirk didn't challenge then made an extra throw on the run down because he was too slow...

Not that Okamota wasn't to blame for all that.  Sigh

[Spanky__99]

1 minute ago, Masterbather said:

At least it's a leverage situation. Not like most of the time when they challenge in the stupidest situations.

1-0 count 2nd inning, stupid.

[JaysFan99]

Thank goodness Sanchez wasn’t out there

[Omar]

4 minutes ago, hanton said:

I'm fairly certain the ABS challenge can be made immediately after that play, for sure on a throw down to 2nd during a steal

Has to made during play not after.

[hanton]

That's a little league HR is Sanchez is in left.  LOL

[Smokinitup420]

Can u imagine Sanchez out there 

[hanton]

Just now, Omar said:

Has to made during play not after.

during live ball?  I doubt that very much

[bronson44]

2 minutes ago, hanton said:

I pretty sure the window to challenge is extended until that play is over, Kirk could then turn to the ump and challenge - has to be done immediately.  

After what though? The whole play resolves? So could he have challenged after the run scored and negated the whole play? He was busy throwing and then covering home so that's a small window in between those 2 to do it, while extremely distracted.

[hanton]

[Spanky__99]

1 minute ago, hanton said:

during live ball?  I doubt that very much

Then just say you don't know?

[Omar]

2 minutes ago, hanton said:

during live ball?  I doubt that very much

Pitcher could have challenged not just catcher if he thought a strike. 

Ceaese should have. Oh well.