The Top 50 Blue Jays of All Time: 30 to 26

[Mike LeSage]

Jays Centre is counting down the top 50 Blue Jays in franchise history. Check out prior entries in the series here:

• Introduction
• 50 to 46
• 45 to 41
• 40 to 36
• 35 to 31

No. 30: Álex Ríos

• 2004-2009
• 2x All-Star

Álex Ríos was selected by Toronto in the first round (19th overall) of the 1999 amateur draft. He would make his debut at the end of May 2004 and stick with the team for five and a half seasons.

Before we started working on our lists for this project, I had already penciled a handful of names in: most of the guys still to come on our countdown, and a lot of the ones already covered (plus a few personal favourites that fell outside of the aggregated top 50). I didn’t initially have Ríos on my list. Maybe it was unfair expectations set on Ríos to begin his career that have tainted my recollection, but I just didn’t remember him being as good as he was.

He entered that ‘04 season as the No. 1 prospect in the organization and No. 6 in all of baseball (future Hall of Famer Joe Mauer was No. 1). Bobby Crosby would win the Rookie of the Year award that season, but Ríos received the second-most votes amongst position players. He is a two-time All-Star, but almost cruelly didn’t make it off of the bench in the 2006 game and only came in as a ninth-inning defensive substitution in 2007 (though he finished second in the ‘07 Home Run Derby, behind Vladimir Guerrero Sr.). The Jays teams he was a part of never made the playoffs, and at their peak, finished 10 games back of the division (‘06).

It’s not Ríos’ fault that he was here for some of the lean years. On top of being a great defender, in ‘07, he led the team in runs (114) and stolen bases (17) and was behind only Frank Thomas for homers (24) and RBI (85). In ‘08, he led the team in runs (91), SB (32) and RBI (79). Those match his two best seasons by Baseball Reference’s WAR with a 5.6 and 5.9, respectively, which rank as the 24th and 28th best seasons for position players in Jays history.

It wasn’t all sunshine and daisies, however. Ríos is also the only Blue Jay in history to strike out five times in a (nine-inning) game on more than one occasion. The second time he ‘accomplished’ that feat came in 2009 during a particularly cold streak that was highlighted by an off-field encounter with a fan after a charity event. That it came the year after he signed the second-most lucrative contract in franchise history, making it all the more unpalatable.

Ríos would arguably get the last laugh; as a member of the Kansas City Royals in his final season, he would have a hand in eliminating the Jays from the 2015 playoffs, going on to become a World Series champion (though his negative WPA through those playoffs suggests he may not have been the catalyst). Whether you look back at Ríos’ time with the Jays fondly, or with a twinge of disappointment (or worse), you can’t argue that he didn’t command a spot on our list.

No. 29: Fred McGriff

• 1986-1990
• Hall of Famer, Silver Slugger, Crime Dog

Fred McGriff was selected by the New York Yankees in the ninth round of the 1981 draft. He was traded in a package to the Jays the following year, when I was just a few months old, and would make his debut in May of 1986. I had McGriff at No. 16 on my list and was worried that I might’ve been ranking with nostalgia-tainted eyes. Not to say that some of my colleagues don’t suffer from the same bias, but I wasn’t even the highest on McGriff, so I feel justified in my opinion.

Fred McGriff was the first Blue Jays player I ever loved. I was young, so a player with a nickname based on an animated crime-fighting dog was right in my wheelhouse. The fact that he could effortlessly crush upper-deck home runs from the left side of the plate was a bonus. His 36 home runs in 1989 were the most of any Toronto player in the '80s not named Barfield or Bell. It was also enough to lead the league that season and helped propel McGriff and the Jays to the only playoff appearance of his tenure and McGriff’s first Silver Slugger Award (he would win one in Toronto and two more elsewhere).

McGriff wouldn’t get another shot at the playoffs with Toronto; after missing out in 1990, he was traded in the offseason, in what is still the biggest trade in franchise history. The four-player deal included two future Hall of Famers, two (and at one time three) members of the Level of Excellence, and four guys that were easy fan-favourites while they played here. As a young fan, I absolutely hated the trade, though by the end of the ‘93 playoffs, I had softened on it slightly. Those early '90s Jays teams were powerhouses, and I’d like to think they still win the back-to-backs with McGriff here, but as things worked out, he would only have to wait a couple of extra years before winning a World Series of his own with the Atlanta Braves.

Somewhat poetically, McGriff's Hall of Fame bid would go the same way: he fell off the ballot initially, only to be enshrined later by the Contemporary Era Committee in 2023. McGriff is one of a small handful of Hall of Famers whose plaque does not have an identifying team. You could make an argument for him wearing a Jays cap, but either way, his journey started as one of Toronto’s best. He’s 13th all-time for home runs (125) and 12th for walks. That combination of power and eye has McGriff sitting third all-time for both on-base and slugging percentages, and he has the highest mark of any Toronto player for adjusted OPS+ at 153.

No. 28: Kelly Gruber

• 1984-1992
• 2x All-Star, Gold Glover, Silver Slugger

Kelly Gruber is an interesting case. He played nine seasons in Toronto, amassed over 3,000 at-bats (19 more than Bo Bichette and good for 21st all-time), and was the first player in franchise history to hit for the cycle – but when I hear his name, there are only two moments that come to mind.

The first is being the guy left holding the ball at the end of the ‘triple play that wasn’t (but really was)’ in Game 3 of the 1992 World Series. The way Gruber ended that play really exemplified his style as a player. It wasn’t nearly as flashy as Devon Whyte’s start to the play (I’m sure we’ll cover him shortly), but it was gritty – a single pump fake and a sprint towards the runner followed by an all-out head-first dive to tag Deion Sanders (Gruber would later reveal that he tore his rotator cuff in the dive, making his bottom of the inning home run all the more heroic).

The other play came in the very next game. With Gruber standing on second base and Whyte at the plate, a hit into left field gave Gruber the opportunity to score. The throw was cut off, so there was never a play at the plate, but Gruber, who would rank higher on an ‘all intensity’ list, again went all-out and head-first in a leaping dive towards home plate that would make Vladdy proud. The dive was less than textbook (partly because of that damaged rotator cuff) and resulted in a bloody chin (and probably a concussion) for Gruber, but it was also the winning run for the Jays.

And we made it this far without mentioning the mullet! All-time great flow. As one of the longest-tenured Jays, Gruber's name is also littered across the career counting stats leaderboards. He’s 23rd all-time for hits (800), 22nd in runs scored (421), 20th for total bases (1335), 19th for home runs (114), 16th for RBI (434) and 14th for stolen bases (80).

Somewhat like Ríos, Gruber’s time in Toronto also ended with some negative feelings after a lucrative extension. In 1991, Gruber signed a three-year, $11 million deal that made him the highest-paid third baseman in the league. In that run to the ‘92 World Series, there was a stretch of the regular season that Gruber spent on the IL with a knee injury. There were also reports that during his time away from the team, he was spotted water skiing and playing tennis near his Muskoka cottage (reports that Gruber denies). Whether there was any truth to those rumours, or if it was just a matter of the accumulated injuries, Toronto cut ties with Gruber after that first championship, sending him to the California Angels in the off-season. Gruber would only play 18 games with the Angels before calling it a career (Luis Sojo, who he was traded for, would only play 19 games with Toronto). We’ve lamented the fact before that there isn’t a standout lifelong Jay. Gruber could have been one.   

No. 27: Russell Martin

• 2015-2019
• All-Star

The 21st Canadian-born player to suit up for Toronto was the most impactful. Russell Martin was born in Toronto, but it wasn’t until he was almost a decade into his illustrious career that he was able to connect with the Jays and join the team in 2015 after signing as a free agent. He would represent the Blue Jays at the All-Star game in his first season with the club and be a large factor in one of the most memorable innings in team history.

Everyone remembers Jose Bautista’s bat flip, but it was Martin behind the plate in the top of the inning who had his throw back to the pitcher freak-ricochet and allow an absolute dirtbag to score and tie the game. Martin has commented publicly that he was thankful to be leading off the bottom of the inning, allowing him to atone for the error. Facing starter Cole Hamels, who was approaching 100 pitches, Martin hit one back up the middle in what could have been a groundout, but in the first of soon to be several errors by the Texas infield, Martin beat out the (lack of a) throw. His hustle on the next grounder helped force another error and allowed him to be subbed out for a pinch-runner. That gave him a front row seat to watch the Bat Flip – a moment Martin has tipped as his favourite in a Jays uniform.

Martin ranks third all-time amongst Jays catchers for fWAR (11.1) and is second all-time for win probability added, lending to the argument that he was the most clutch Canadian this franchise has seen.

No. 26: Paul Molitor

• 1993-1995
• Hall of Famer, World Series MVP, 2x All-Star, Silver Slugger

Over a 12-game stretch in the fall of 1993, Paul Molitor racked up 21 hits (four doubles, three triples, three home runs), 17 runs, 13 RBI, a 244 wRC+ and a stolen base. With the exception of the stolen base, all those other stats were the best on the team and propelled the Jays to the second of their back-to-back World Series wins and earned Molitor the second WS MVP in franchise history.

Molitor signed as a free agent for that ‘93 season, replacing Dave Winfield as the team’s designated hitter – and hit he did. Molitor led the entire league with 211 hits (he would lead the league three times in his career, once with each team he played for) and finished the season with the fourth best bWAR on the team.

The righty batter was with Toronto for three seasons and “only” 1,615 at bats, so he lags behind slightly in some of the career counting stats, but his .315 BA over those three seasons is the best the Jays have ever seen. Those 211 hits in ‘93 are the third-best the team has ever seen in a single season. The 121 runs he scored that same year are tied for the fifth best mark. Molitor would move on ahead of the 1996 season, vacating the DH spot for a player we’ll be covering a little higher up the list, but his impact was felt in the time he was here. It’s hard to look at the playoff run in ‘93 and find a way for the Jays to prevail without him.

View full article

[Spanky__99]

I'll agree with you on the Crimedog being to low, Jesus man?!