GDT (1/3): Detroit Tigers @ Toronto Blue Jays - Sanchez vs. Dickey - 7:07 ET

[Orgfiller]

Yes! Inconclusive!

[Orgfiller]

Do you think it's fair to give the team back their challenge if it's inconclusive? Not really fair if they were right to challenge but no camera can confirm?

 

That would definitely be fair, good suggestion.

[Rajais Mitten]

FYI the Orioles wont f***ing stop 4-0 top of the 3rd

[IBTrini]

Nice Goins, the squeeze worked...fundamentals, what? lol

That was nice to see - good decision and nice outcome.

[bronson44]

Do you think it's fair to give the team back their challenge if it's inconclusive? Not really fair if they were right to challenge but no camera can confirm?

 

They are judging their decision whether to challenge or not based on the same video.

[JaysFan4Ever]

Rally time!

[Dylan]

They are judging their decision whether to challenge or not based on the same video.

Can they really see all the angles we have in those few seconds before challenging though? and zoomed in.

[JaysFan4Ever]

Esmil Rogers starting for the Yankees?

[Dylan]

Melky!!!

[Dylan]

This can't be on the turf!! or could it??

 

http://www.reactiongifs.com/r/bml.gif

[jaysfan2014]

Will someone please get a decent LF in Detroit already? Another bad play by JD Martinez.

[Candy Maldonado]

hit everything to LF!

[Rajais Mitten]

Martinez retires by the end of this game

[burlingtonbandit]

That would definitely be fair, good suggestion.

 

The counter argument to that is that encourages more challenges which slows the game down even more. Game is already really slow so I wouldn't be a fan of that.

 

My suggestion is to have all reviews come from the booth much like NCAA football.

[Orgfiller]

LOL Martinez, Goins would've been out by a mile, Rivera derped on that play but got lucky.

[CJ-Freeway]

LOL Martinez's WAR should go down by 5 full points llol

[Dylan]

jose!!!!!!!!

[JaysFan4Ever]

Will someone please get a decent LF in Detroit already? Another bad play by JD Martinez.

 

Better them screwing up in the field than our guy

[kcjaysfan]

Heh, they gave Kawasaki a double.

[jaysfan2014]

This is more the Anibal Sanchez that has been sucking in Detroit lately, especially since July. And with no offense, Detroit is digging itself in a deep hole.

[IBTrini]

FYI the Orioles wont f***ing stop 4-0 top of the 3rd

... and the Indians' D is making it easy for NYY.

[Dylan]

The counter argument to that is that encourages more challenges which slows the game down even more. Game is already really slow so I wouldn't be a fan of that.

 

My suggestion is to have all reviews come from the booth much like NCAA football.

 

Do you think teams would risk it being inconclusive? They will obviously make some changes this offseason.. they have to!

[burlingtonbandit]

Do you think teams would risk it not being inconclusive? They will obviously make some changes this offseason.. they have to!

 

Bottom line is you would still get more challenges than now.

[havok24]

More posting starts for Orgfiller please.

[Dylan]

Woooooo...they came to play tonight.

 

clearly the tigers didn't, haha!

[jaysfan2014]

As for the O's.. the Cardinals are still struggling with their offense. I still think St. Louis could miss the playoffs if their offense doesn't improve, especially with a surging(and far superior) Pittsburgh Pirates team.

[burlingtonbandit]

Good try Navarro. Nice swing

[jaysfan2014]

JD Martinez finally makes a catch..

[Dylan]

Good inning boys!

[immature]

Let's go jays