If we went into the playoffs today, what does your rotation look like?

[admin]

If we went to the playoffs today, and had to pick three starters, who are they and what order do you put them in?

Buehrle is pitching over his head, but I think he has to get the ball.

Then I think I'd go with Stroman (I'd really wait to see how he finishes the year, but that goes against my question)

Then I'd go with Dickey I guess. But I'd hope it's a pitcher we pick up.

[admin]

Holy crap knew Hutch's numbers on the road were better, didn't know that much of a difference.

[o2cui2i]

you only need a 3 man rotation and everyone else goes to the pen.

 

I'd send Buehrle out for game 1 knowing he could pitch just as well in game 4 if needed.

 

I'd start Stroman on day 2 and hutch on day 3.

 

Dickey becomes a relief guy.

[eastcoastjaysfan]

Would depend on the team. If they're a bit lefty heavy I would go with Happ over Dickey.

[GD]

1. Lee

2. Price

3. Samardzija

[Daniel Labude]

Stroman, Buehrle, Hutch

[jayswin11]

Buehrle

Stroman

Hutch

 

Dickey to the pen.

[dineke]

f*** it,

 

1. Stroman for every game.

[G-Snarls]

Buerhle

Stroman

Hutchison

 

Then either Happ or Dickey if needed depending on the schedule and the opposing lineup

[jays4life19]

Stroman

Dickey

Hutch

Buehrle

 

This.

[TheHurl]

Stroman

Dickey

Hutch

Buehrle

 

Can't upset the veteran and probable all star. Buehrle will go out game one.

[Governator]

I'd have to say it depends who were playing and what games were home vs away.

[TheHurl]

I'd have to say it depends who were playing and what games were home vs away.

 

well since we are saying "if today" it would be against Detroit on the road.

[Governator]

well since we are saying "if today" it would be against Detroit on the road.

 

Then I'd go with:

 

Buerhle

Hutch

Stro show

 

Buerhle/Hutch pitch on the road against Tigers, stro/buerhle would pitch home games and hutch in the 5th game if needed on the road.

[Sparky12]

I gotta go buehrle, hutch, Stroman, I have little faith in Dickey.

[wilko]

Buerhle

Hutchison

Morrow