Official Fantasy Baseball Advice Thread

[Daniel Labude]

Depends on the team. a contender in need of a SS and steals, make the deal. a weaker team, don't make the deal.

 

significant red flags with the hit tool of Gorman and Lewis

 

This is my thought process as well. Currently I'm stacked but lacking SP due to injuries and almost no bench

 

I would have

 

Vlad

Hiura

Story

LeMahieu

Harper

Robert

Happ

Donaldson

[Carlos Danger]

30 team dynasty

 

Meadows, Royce Lewis, Nolan Gorman, Alex Reyes

 

For

 

Trevor Story

 

Debating if this is worth it. On the surface it is, but a lot to give up

 

IMO Story

 

The four offer guys all took a hits in fantasy value in the leagues I am in and the last 3 especially.. So Story for Meadows and depreciating assets IMO... Hard No!

[Brian Labude]

Thoughts on this offer I got in one of my 30 team dynasty leagues (it caused an argument) when the dude was just pounding sand saying Bundy was equal to Giolito

 

Cavan Biggio and Dylan Bundy

For

Lucas Giolito and Franmil Reyes

[Laika]

What are the hitting stats?

[Brian Labude]

what are the hitting stats?

 

r

hr

rbi

sb

avg

ops

rc

[Laika]

Gio side. He's the best player, and I don't think it's close.

[Carlos Danger]

Thoughts on this offer I got in one of my 30 team dynasty leagues (it caused an argument) when the dude was just pounding sand saying Bundy was equal to Giolito

 

Cavan Biggio and Dylan Bundy

For

Lucas Giolito and Franmil Reyes

 

Are you looking to join another Dynasty League....?

[Spanky__99]

Are you looking to join another Dynasty League....?

 

Yeah, his bro is in that league, although I vaguely remember him denying a spot, but that was in the past. Join up Condor.

[Brian Labude]

Yeah, his bro is in that league, although I vaguely remember him denying a spot, but that was in the past. Join up Condor.

 

What league, if its free im in (kinda maxed out on pay leagues right now)

[connorp]

What league, if its free im in (kinda maxed out on pay leagues right now)

 

You’ll prob want to re-tool being a dynasty league and all. You could have worse to start with I guess. PM me Yelich when you get settled. I’d offer Grade A spects

[Carlos Danger]

Dynasty, H2H.

 

 

Gore & Buehler for Jose Ramirez and Merrifield.

 

Which side do you like better?

[Jimcanuck]

Dynasty, H2H.

 

 

Gore & Buehler for Jose Ramirez and Merrifield.

 

Which side do you like better?

 

Hitters if have enough other pitchers and in win now mode. Pitchers otherwise.

 

Merrifield will soon be a deep league option only.

[Spanky__99]

Dynasty, H2H.

 

 

Gore & Buehler for Jose Ramirez and Merrifield.

 

Which side do you like better?

 

Bats, easy.

[Carlos Danger]

Thanks guys... The same guy also suggested a modification.

 

Buehler & Gore for Yelich and his 1st rnd FYPD

 

So the options are:

 

Buehler & Gore for Yelich and his 1st rnd FYPD

 

Buehler and Gore for Jose Ramirez & Whitfield.

 

 

Thanks!

[Spanky__99]

Thanks guys... The same guy also suggested a modification.

 

Buehler & Gore for Yelich and his 1st rnd FYPD

 

So the options are:

 

Buehler & Gore for Yelich and his 1st rnd FYPD

 

Buehler and Gore for Jose Ramirez & Whitfield.

 

 

Thanks!

 

Option B for bats!

[BlueRocky]

If I’m not in win now mode I’d likely keep Buehler and Gore. Ramirez is really good though.

 

Yelich had a terrible .259 BABIP and still put up 113 wRC+. It’s not hard to imagine him bouncing back to near 2018-2019.

[Jimcanuck]

I don't put much value on Merrifield at this point in his career.

[Laika]

I think those are tough deals to evaluate. In both the big bat is the single best asset - Yelich and Ramirez are studs - but the Buehler + Gore package is substantial. I'd probably take the big bat but letting Buehler go would not be easy.

[Carlos Danger]

I think those are tough deals to evaluate. In both the big bat is the single best asset - Yelich and Ramirez are studs - but the Buehler + Gore package is substantial. I'd probably take the big bat but letting Buehler go would not be easy.

 

I feel the same. I generally gravitate hitters over pitchers, but Buehler + Gore could be a 1, 2 Fantasy knock out punch..

[Carlos Danger]

Option B for bats!

 

Well, I chose option B, and I got the guy to send me a 4th rnd pick also

 

Thanks for all your help!

[Carlos Danger]

Dynasty H2H

 

Would you keep Tucker or:

 

Mancini, 2021 FYPD, 1.5, Gurriel and Ethan Hankins OR Daniel Lynch (only one of the two).

 

Or

 

Mancini, 2021 FYPD 1.5, Gallen, Ethan Hankins OR Daniel Lynch (only one of the two).

 

Thanks

Edited February 25, 2021 by Carlos Danger

[Laika]

Dynasty HTH

 

Would you keep Tucker or:

 

Mancini, 2021 FYPD, 1.5, Gurriel and Ethan Hankins OR Daniel Lynch (only one of the two).

 

Or

 

Mancini, 2021 FYPD 1.5, Gallen, Ethan Hankins OR Daniel Lynch (only one of the two).

 

Thanks

 

Depending on roster constraints I'd probably do that trade, taking the Gallen package and Lynch.

[connorp]

Riley Greene vs oft-injured Aaron Judge. Dynasty. What would you need to add in prospect capital? Asking for a friend

[BTS]

Riley Greene vs oft-injured Aaron Judge. Dynasty. What would you need to add in prospect capital? Asking for a friend

 

A lot

[Laika]

Riley Greene vs oft-injured Aaron Judge. Dynasty. What would you need to add in prospect capital? Asking for a friend

 

Greene should probably be the 2nd piece.

[connorp]

RG is basically Kelenic+ after ST. Haters

[Laika]

RG is basically Kelenic+ after ST. Haters

 

You obviously don't believe this if you are shopping him for an injury prone slugger leaving their physical prime soon.

[connorp]

You obviously don't believe this if you are shopping him for an injury prone slugger leaving their physical prime soon.

 

After Royce Lewis I’m questioning the wisdom in holding stocks in one basket rather than diversifying. Plus I kind of want to win now in one of the leagues as I’m on the cusp. Just thought of it anyway

[BTS]

After Royce Lewis I’m questioning the wisdom in holding stocks in one basket rather than diversifying. Plus I kind of want to win now in one of the leagues as I’m on the cusp. Just thought of it anyway

 

Oh you don’t like Royce Lewis anymore? He was a pretty big part of your Trout offer. I can’t believe you were trying to bamboozle me.

[Jimcanuck]

After Royce Lewis I’m questioning the wisdom in holding stocks in one basket rather than diversifying. Plus I kind of want to win now in one of the leagues as I’m on the cusp. Just thought of it anyway

 

You should trade high on all your helium 'spects. Come at me, bro.