Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Is Matt Manning such a AAAA guy that he can strike guys out in AAA all day, but can't ever produce decent K numbers in the show... Looking more likely by the minute.
Posted (edited)

He wasn’t awful the first start.

Also don’t exactly see guys like Nimmo, Lindor, Alonso in triple-A.

 

Manning’s stuff+ actually looks decent, all three pitches graded average or better in 2023. Most notably the slider was well above average. The 7.9% SwStr% seems to be the issue.

He gave up way too many fly balls and hard contact, bottom 9% percentile in giving up barrels isn’t a good recipe. Fly balls + hard contact + low swinging strikes.

 

I don’t watch him enough to pinpoint the issues, but possibly needs better command as pitches getting too much plate, or there’s not enough separation between his pitches to induce swinging strikes.

 

You can kinda get away with it in triple-A but not the big leagues.

Edited by BlueRocky
Community Moderator
Posted
Made a channel in Fantrax to post debut Waivers announcements and requests
Posted
Wtf is going on with Esteury Ruiz? Hits we'll, gets sent down, starts randomly hitting jacks like he never has in his life. Including MLB jacks in the last few games
  • 4 weeks later...
Old-Timey Member
Posted
Just that I don't think people had the expectation he would be at otherwordly ace level when he signed, did they?
Posted
Just that I don't think people had the expectation he would be at otherwordly ace level when he signed, did they?

 

No doubt, projected as a mid rotation arm.

Community Moderator
Posted
Who the f*** is David Fry and why is he hitting like Mike Piazza?

 

I'm not sure he's made a single out since I dropped him a few weeks ago

Posted
I'm not sure he's made a single out since I dropped him a few weeks ago

 

I also owned a share in David Fry for maybe a week or so earlier in the season ugh.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
crazy trade but maybe Skenes is actually Strasburg

 

He very well might be. But I pretty much had no choice when the idea of getting Acuna came up. Gotta shoot for the big get's when you have the chance.

Community Moderator
Posted
Selling Acuna for a pitcher? Feels like a bad idea.

 

Unfortunately, I consider Acuna to have a similar risk profile to someone like Skenes at this point. Right ACL in 2021, then tweaked that knee again in ST and never looked quite right, then tore the left ACL. He might be permanently compromised. Or maybe AA shows some balls, bans him from playing winter league, and he's the top fantasy player in the league again.

 

I might have had tunnel vision with Skenes, but I think he's a top-5 dynasty pitcher, and I don't see why he can't have a Strasburg/Wheeler career. He checks basically every box that can be checked for me.

Community Moderator
Posted
Seriously though, why are players with hundred million dollar contracts playing competitive ball in the offseason? It's completely absurd.
Posted
Seriously though, why are players with hundred million dollar contracts playing competitive ball in the offseason? It's completely absurd.

 

Probably the same reason I play simulator golf in the winter. Keep the game sharp.

Posted
Seriously though, why are players with hundred million dollar contracts playing competitive ball in the offseason? It's completely absurd.

 

Honestly I don’t think this is impacting the wear and tear all that much, players like RAJ aren’t treating these games with the same intensity, it’s just additional practice. Unfortunately Acuña is built different, and not in a good way. He clearly had bad knees if this is already such a major issue this early in his career.

  • 3 weeks later...
Community Moderator
Posted
Yeah so… Skenes might already be the best pitcher in baseball.

 

I've seen all of 35 innings of him. But the only active pitcher who I think is as impressive is DeGrom. The stuff is one thing, but Skenes commands 100 on the black basically every game, and most games commands the 95 mph splinker. And also has a plus slider. It's outrageous. If he can get through the next 20 years with only 1-2 catastrophic injuries he's going to have an insane career.

Posted
Yeah so… Skenes might already be the best pitcher in baseball.

 

I was thinking of driving down to Pittsburgh this weekend, since he might pitch on Saturday most likely.

Posted
I've seen all of 35 innings of him. But the only active pitcher who I think is as impressive is DeGrom. The stuff is one thing, but Skenes commands 100 on the black basically every game, and most games commands the 95 mph splinker. And also has a plus slider. It's outrageous. If he can get through the next 20 years with only 1-2 catastrophic injuries he's going to have an insane career.

 

Strider when he is on is right up there

Community Moderator
Posted
I've seen all of 35 innings of him. But the only active pitcher who I think is as impressive is DeGrom. The stuff is one thing, but Skenes commands 100 on the black basically every game, and most games commands the 95 mph splinker. And also has a plus slider. It's outrageous. If he can get through the next 20 years with only 1-2 catastrophic injuries he's going to have an insane career.

 

I think because his fastball shape isn't amazing, a lot will depend on how his velo holds up over time.

Community Moderator
Posted
Strider when he is on is right up there

 

Strider is pretty boring. Two great pitches but it's like watching a closer throw bulk innings.

Posted
Tim Lincecum in 2008 and 2009 was one of the most dominating and fun starters I've watched. I purchased MLB Extra Innings those years to watch every start of his.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...