Jump to content
Jays Centre
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
Maybe it's a case of loving what you have, but I wouldn't trade Corey Seager for Correa, and I'd trade Seager for Bryant without hesitation.
Posted
Maybe it's a case of loving what you have, but I wouldn't trade Corey Seager for Correa, and I'd trade Seager for Bryant without hesitation.

 

Well that's because Seager is better than Correa so there's actually an argument to be made there. Don't think I'd take Seager over Bryant in fantasy, mayyybe irl but I'd have to be persuaded.

 

Come at me haters.

Posted
Well that's because Seager is better than Correa so there's actually an argument to be made there. Don't think I'd take Seager over Bryant in fantasy, mayyybe irl but I'd have to be persuaded.

 

Come at me haters.

 

That's a hot take right there! I'd take Bryant IRL, only because I'm not convinced that Seager's D will rate as well going forward. He's more likely to move to 3B than Correa IMO, but I don't see either one moving in the next 3 years.

Posted
That's a hot take right there! I'd take Bryant IRL, only because I'm not convinced that Seager's D will rate as well going forward. He's more likely to move to 3B than Correa IMO, but I don't see either one moving in the next 3 years.

 

I disagree with the last part. I think Correa is already bulkier than Seager, and the former's defense already rates as below average for the position. While both will probably end up moving, I think Correa is the one who'll force the transition sooner lest they allow him to stay at short and hurt the defense while providing excellent offensive contribution.

 

Definitely Bryant over both though.

Posted
This draft talk is depressing, I just got reminded that we took D.J. Davis over Corey Seager and Max Pentecost over Trea Turner.
Posted
It's close. Bryant > Correa > Seager for me. Though Correa could flip it easily. Bryant was starting AA at Correa's age.
Posted
It's close. Bryant > Correa > Seager for me. Though Correa could flip it easily. Bryant was starting AA at Correa's age.

 

Seager is Correa's age and has a considerably more impressive resume.

Posted
Yeah I'm not going all the way back to the Chad Jenkins over Trout days.

 

How do 15 teams get mike trout wrong in that draft.... It truly is baffling that nobody saw that this kid was going to be the best baseball player in a generation.

Posted
How do 15 teams get mike trout wrong in that draft.... It truly is baffling that nobody saw that this kid was going to be the best baseball player in a generation.

 

I thought he went 25th? :P

Posted
I thought he went 25th? :P

 

I thought he went in the teens but i could be wrong.... That is worse yet..... Still i make my point

Community Moderator
Posted
It's close. Bryant > Correa > Seager for me. Though Correa could flip it easily. Bryant was starting AA at Correa's age.

 

Yeah.

 

With players this talented there is also a lot of variance (so far to fall). So, it's basically a situation where you can't go right/wrong and any of them could blow the other two away.

Posted
Shields is pissed for getting pulled, I don't blame him cause, now I'm pissed.

 

Do you own James Shields? And if so, why?

Posted
Do you own James Shields? And if so, why?

 

Like I told BTS, he's only one year removed from being half decent. So far, so good... save for the moron manager that dropped an IBB on Lindor after that lead-off double. He'd only given up i hit prior the Lindor dinger in the first and was near perfect up to that point, with 6 K's and a BB. He was doing alright in his first start too, until he walked the park. He hasn't been bad.

Posted
Like I told BTS, he's only one year removed from being half decent. So far, so good... save for the moron manager that dropped an IBB on Lindor after that lead-off double. He'd only given up i hit prior the Lindor dinger in the first and was near perfect up to that point, with 6 K's and a BB.

 

But he's 35 and just had one of the worst pitching seasons that I can recall. This is usually when people jump ship on a player. It's not like there's any sort of upside to him, the projections have him as a workhorse type garbage pitcher.

Posted
I have him pitching against you today, meat. Aren't you Bye Week in the BBDL?

 

Well this is the DDL thread. Although the fact that you doubled down on James Shields is definitely an interesting strategy.

Posted
But he's 35 and just had one of the worst pitching seasons that I can recall. This is usually when people jump ship on a player. It's not like there's any sort of upside to him, the projections have him as a workhorse type garbage pitcher.

 

He met my 20, bro... dead cat bounce back... own him in 3 leagues. Well, I picked him off waivers in the other 2, lol. Also, that's another reason I kept him, rather than stream.

Posted
He met my 20, bro... dead cat bounce back... own him in 3 leagues. Well, I picked him off waivers in the other 2, lol.

 

Not here, was just talking about ball. I'd have been pissed 2.

Community Moderator
Posted
lol Correa won't be moving off SS for a very long time.

 

But the scouts say he's too tall...

Posted
But the scouts say he's too tall...

 

I'm honestly disappointed this conversation is even happening here. Derek Jeter stayed at SS his whole career even when a much better defender joined the team. As long as Correa is adequate at SS and probably even if he gets pretty bad, he's staying at short.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Dinger, where we having the Keon Broxton fap sesh?
It's at my place. You guys are welcome to join. BYOD.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund
The Jays Centre Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Blue Jays community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...