If you're not happy with WAR evaluation for 1B, I am happy to use offensive stats only. Vlad is 7th this year among 1Bs with little separation between him and 13th place. He is the MLB leader in GIDP and 5th worst 1B in base running. Basically, Vlad has been an average 1B at best this year. Objectively speaking, it would be extremely stupid to give Vlad a mega contract based on recent and career numbers. Anything more than the Matt Olson's extension would be an overpay.