You guys gotta stop focusing so much on run differential, Michael Kay has finally gotten to you. Literally a month into the year the Yankees had a differential over 100 runs than the Jays. I just pulled it up, and May 19th they were +118 to the Jays.
Yankees beat up some bad teams for a couple weeks and you completely forget their bullpen blow ups and awful defense, both of which will come back to bite them in the playoffs.