I'm sure I could live with it but Osuna has a ceiling similar to Carrasco as a starter, so I'd like to actually see how he actually does next year as one first. Pompey could become an excellent top of the order bat next season with his new high OBP approach and low k-rate. Vlad Jr is far off but he may have the best ceiling of all.
If we part with one, I'd rather it be Pompey, while keeping Alford.