I’ve put some thought into this recently. This class is exceptionally deep even in the late 1st/early second, so it’s a plausible strategy. It’s kinda like what they did with Groshans/Kloff in 2018.
We’ll be essentially trading the 5th pick for 12th + 25th (The second guy will likely be an over-slot 2nd/3rd that was a projected 1st rounder that dropped). Bottom line, it really depends which of the big 5 end up not getting picked.
First of, there’s no chance Austin Martin is getting past the Marlins and Royals, so we can rule him out.
It’s also hard to believe Torkelson will get passed 4 times, but let’s say there’s a slim chance.
If either Tork, Nicky G, or Hancock is there at 5, you pretty much take it and run.
The two guys that could go 5, but I have mild reservations about Asa Lacy (some pitchability concerns, reliever risk, and funky mechanics) and Mitchell (offensive tools, power is raw, type 1 diabetic), both have their tremendous upside but also flaws to nitpick.
If we do go under-slot at #5, we’re basically looking at what we would draft at a typical year where we pick 11 to 12.
The names I would look at for #5 under-slot (@12 money) would be:
Hitter: Austin Hendrick, Zac Veen, Pete Crow-Armstrong, Casey Martin, Heston Kjerstad, Robert Hassell
Pitcher: Reid Detmers, Jared Kelley, Carmen Mlodzinski, Garrett Crochet, Cole Wilcox
That’s not a bad pool of guys, I feel it’s similarly talented to this crop of mid-later 1st round from 2018:
Groshans, Rodriguez, Liberatore, Singer, Larnarch, Naylor, McClanahan, Kowar.
Simeon Woods-Richardson was also taken 48th that year.
In the 2nd/3rd round we’d be looking at names like:
Max Meyer, JT Ginn (elbow surgery), Alika Williams, Blaze Jordan, Masyn Winn, Jordan Walker, Daniel Cabrera, Alejandro Rosario, Dylan Crews, Gage Workman, Slade Cecconi, Cam Brown, Daxton Fulton (TJ)