My girlfriend and I were discussing the other day which of the team's recent playoff series wins is/was the most satisfying as we enter 2017.
The 2015 ALDS has obviously become iconic as a cheesy Hollywood script turned into real life. Huge postseason drought ends, team limps out of the gate and gets their backs pressed against the wall in Games 1 and 2, recovers against impressive odds through Games 3 and 4, and caps it off with a win in Game 5 in perhaps the most memorable, oddball, and cathartic inning anyone will ever witness. Bautista immortalizes himself in Toronto sports history at the expense of the Texas Rangers' dignity.
The 2016 WC game involved going up against a bitter rival that arguably lucked their way into the postseason. With the better team on paper, the Blue Jays needed to eliminate Baltimore to even justify the season -- especially considering the Blue Jays needed to force this game over the season's final weekend due to poor play through September. Game ends because of a legendary poor decision by an overrated manager and Edwin putting himself right next to Bautista in Toronto sports lore by ripping the Orioles' hearts out.
The 2016 ALDS was a rematch against the incredibly salty Texas team from the 2015 ALDS. A running rivalry through the season capped off with huge brawl and suspensions across the board. Certain Rangers players and their fans reveled in Odor punching Bautista on the field, treating it like schoolyard payback for last year's failures. Outside of the obvious bad blood (which both teams controlled), the ALDS itself was relatively drama-free. Both Ranger aces got their asses shown to them in Games 1 and 2 and Texas put the screws to the Jays' ace in Game 3 (while still watching their own mediocre starter get trashed). Desperate reporters and on-edge fans speculated about a similar table-turning as 2015's series, but this time in Texas's favour. Unfortunately for the Rangers' dignity, a surprisingly tight Game 3 ended in yet another Blue Jays triumph via a throwing error by folk hero Rougned Odor. At this point, no retaliation in 2017 will ever look like anything but the sourest of grapes from a franchise trying to take the crown of being perennial choke artists and f*** ups from the 1990s and 2000s Atlanta Braves.