imo, both Gibby & AA will be back next season to have another kick at the can. Attendance is down but nothing crazy and it was expected. Viewership has been decent, especially during the recent "hope" phase during the Cubs series. Rogers looks at this & says AA/Gibby can still sell hope for next year ie. we were that close, injuries, imagine if we were healthy all year, young exciting arms, team is deeper, etc.
The way the O's play is reflective of Showalter. The way the Rays play is reflective of Maddon. Managers imo make a huge difference on culture and the way the team plays. Maybe Gibbons biggest asset for this team is he lets them play loose without as much "structure" as other top teams, maybe not.
That said, I like Gibby - the guys respect him & like him. He loves Toronto the city & team, & that in itself gets him points.
Gibby or not, in an ideal world imo, jays have one manager for a long period of time. 2 years in an out stuff is amateurish.
flawed as this team is, don't think anyone has any issue of this team making the playoffs next year & playing a meaningful series of playoff baseball at a minimum. If that means AA/Gibby stick around for another few years, so be it.