As for Andrus, his wRC+ has been far inferior, from 2009-present:
81, 75, 93, 97, 79, 79. And his defensive numbers are already slipping based on UZR/150: 13.3, 1.8, 7.5, 8.5, 5.0, -4.4. Where did his defense go? Is he hiding an injury, or is he already in decline? That 2014 number (-4.4), is only slightly better than Reyes, who was at -6.6.. but Reyes has never been known for defense, being a similar player to Derek Jeter, but with more speed.